Update on my second mini with a dead Thunderbolt port after second visit to Genius Bar …
Recap:
- First mini's Tb port died within a week.
- Genius at Apple Store refused to look at it saying it was a common problem.
- Returned for refund.
- Waited until firmware update for HDMI port out.
- Reordered.
- Tb port on second mini died in less than 24 hours.
- Senior Apple tech said to visit Apple Store again and insist on having mini and Tb->DVI adapter tested.
- Visited Genius Bar today and spoke to a different genius than the first visit.
Result: It was the adapter.
While I won't be fully convinced until this mini with new DVI adapter is solid until it's run flawlessly for two weeks, I must say this refusal by the first genius to test the adapter wasted many hours of my time and some gas money.
I'm going to detail the test steps taken at the Genius Bar because it wasn't smooth and perhaps others can pick up a hint or two.
Diagnostic steps:
- Connect mini with my Apple-branded DVI adapter to Apple's monitor. Dead.
- Connect mini with Apple's VGA adapter. Worked.
- Connect mini with Apple's DVI adapter. Dead. Maybe different pins/drivers involved so mini still defective?
- Connect mini with second Apple DVI adapter. Dead. Yup, seems to be a dead Tb port when using DVI.
- Now test my DVI adapter with their computer in case of double failure.
- Connect Apple laptop with my DVI adapter to Apple monitor. Dead. Both mini and DVI adapter dead?!?!
- Connect Apple laptop with Apple DVI adapter. Dead. ***?! My mini killed their adapter?
- Check DVI connector on back of monitor. Oops! Loose DVI cable. (Tighten those cables on the back of your monitors, folks)
- Recheck Apple laptop with Apple DVI adapter. Works. OK, loose cable at monitor confirmed.
- Recheck Apple laptop with my DVI adapter. Dead. So if it's dead, maybe mini is OK?
- Recheck mini with Apple DVI connector. Works. Great! It's not the mini.
- Recheck mini with my DVI connector. Dead.
- Looks like a DVI adapter swap is required.
- Check new DVI adapter with mini. Works.
Conclusion: Bad DVI adapter. No idea why it resurrected for the second mini only to die again later.
On the recommendation of the senior Apple tech, I will be providing polite, but strongly worded feedback to http://apple.com/retail/feedback/
When I think of the hours I wasted setting up the first mini, the time & gas money for the useless first visit to the Apple Store, rolling back to my laptop, wiping and reinstalling the OS to return the mini, setting up the second mini, rolling back to my laptop again, and then syncing back to the mini today, well, you can imagine my level of dissatisfaction.
So folks, if the Apple Genius tries to brush you off, insist that they do the diagnostics no matter how many times they've seen the problem.
If I encounter any problems with this second adapter, I assure you I'll be back to let you know. :-)