You can make a difference in the Apple Support Community!

When you sign up with your Apple Account, you can provide valuable feedback to other community members by upvoting helpful replies and User Tips.

Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

Major bug: Audio Levels incorrect on export

Here's what I'm trying to do and the frustrating results I'm getting. The idea (and the client's specs) is to export a ProRes file with discrete audio channels. 24 in my case each being a discrete mono track. We've been doing this in FCP7 over 4 years now without any issues. When trying to replicate that same workflow inFCP X, I get incorrect results. So I ran a quick test to see if FCP X is messing with audio levels on share or export for those of us who deliver to the gazillion providers other than YouTube.


In FCP X, I import a mono (not stereo or dual-mono, just plain mono) reference tone at -20 dBFS. My project is set to surround (this is for multichannel projects).

In the timeline it plays at the the correct level" -20dBFS and all looks and sounds good. My file is 24 bit 48kHZ so is my project. I also have FCP X being monitored through a Videotek for measurements.

User uploaded file


The imported tone is measured and confirmed to be at -20 dBFS on the Videotek, as well as in Audition CS6; straight from the file to eliminate any patch cord speculation:

User uploaded file

I assign a role called TONE to the audio clip and export role as separate file.

With PAN MODE set to NONE and channel configuration set to MONO I get an exported audio file that is 2.67 dB quieter than my original file.

User uploaded file


So I try a different approach: I set PAN MODE to Default and channel configuration to mono. I get a file that is 6.02 dB quieter than my original file.

User uploaded file


So last try: I set the channel configuration to CENTER and the PAN MODE to NONE. I get another file that is 6.02 dB quieter.

User uploaded file

The logical outcome even with pan laws in mind, should be: you import an audio file at -20 dBFS, you verify that the audio levels are correct with the audio meters, you export it and you get an identical -20 dBFS audio file.

I do this all the time in FCP7: you set your audio channels to mono and set the pan law to 0 dBin your sequence settings. done.

So what is going on in FCP X? I know a whole bunch of post houses deliver files for broadcast. Do they all have these incorrect levels? Or do the editors compensate with a gain of 2.67db or 6.02 dB according to the audio configuration. Which mind you is unacceptable because if the FCP X meters say my reference tone is sitting at -20 dBFS then my exported file should be -20 dBFS not some arbitrary number.

I ran this test on multiple machines: MacPro Mountain Lion 10.8.2, Macbook Pro ML 10.8.2, MacPro Snow Leopard 10.6.8 and I get the same results.

Anyway, I'm really suprised that on this board I only found a handfull of threads that mentioned this issue. None had any solution or explanation for this behaviour on export. Yet, it is a pretty serious one. Am I not doing it right? But then I had other people try on their own and they are reported the same thing.

Any light shed on this issue would be most appreciated. Until then, FCP 7 and Pro Tools are my only hope.

Final Cut Pro X, OS X Mountain Lion (10.8.2)

Posted on Nov 4, 2012 1:31 PM

Reply
16 replies

Major bug: Audio Levels incorrect on export

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.