Well said.
I am also resolutely committed to retaining the indispensible capabilities of iTunes 10.7.
And likewise, I couldn’t care less about the voting feature of iTunes DJ. But I DO use iTunes DJ for 2-3 hours EVERY DAY to stream a fresh menu of music from my library – a music stream that I’ve never heard before and will never hear again. All with ZERO intervention required on the part of the listener.
At the opposite extreme from the serendipity you can enjoy with iTunes DJ, iTunes 10.7 is also far more helpful than iTunes 11, should you prefer instead to create meticulously “composed” playlists of specific songs designed to play in specific order. For example, in iTunes 11 it is not possible to open two playlists in separate windows, then select a song from Playlist A, and drag it precisely into the 5th playback position of Playlist B. Multiple windows are a pretty basic requirement if you want to do detail oriented work with playlists (just as they are in the case of Excel spreadsheets or Word documents), but iTunes 11 eliminates support for multiple windows.
Finally, for those of us who have invested considerable effort in assembling good quality artwork for the albums in our libraries, the essential banishment of album art from iTunes 11 (except for thumbnail views) is incomprehensible. For those who considered the presentation of album art in iTunes 10.7 to be useless bloat, it was quite a simple matter to switch it off. But – incredibly – there is no way to switch it ON in iTunes 11.
We are witnessing here the larger strategy of transforming the Mac version of iTunes into iTunes for iPad. Or “iTunes Lite,” if you prefer. In fact, Apple seems to be redefining the concept of “innovation” as that process by which incredibly useful (and enjoyable) features that were previously developed, deployed and supported are unceremoniously dumped from the platform. The day may not be far off when you can only get whatever functionality Apple decides to provide via iCloud incarnations of strategic apps. Oddly enough, that’s exactly the Big Brother model, which Apple’s 1984 Super Bowl commercial so famously railed against.