Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

Advice on purchasing a new computer for print and web design on a budget.

Recently the hard drive on my late 2006 Imac failed. I am now trying to decide what to replace it with and can’t settle on a comfortable solution.


I am a print designer who works on catalogs and photobooks and also does some web design. Until it died, the Imac was adequate. Though it had only 1GB of ram and a 250GB hard drive I was running CS3 comfortably on the machine. I had about 100GB of data that I accessed regularly from an external drive and was using about 175GB of the machine’s internal hard drive.



I’m hesitant to spend $1299 on a new Imac because money is a bit tight and I have some reservations about working on a glossy screen. I was immediately attracted to buying the basic Mac Mini for $599 and a monitor, which I figured would cost me about $200, saving me around $500. I see that the Mini has a dual-core processor (same as my old Imac) and 4gb of memory (4x that of my old machine). This would be a step up, but will it be adequate working on modern browsers and new CS software 3-4 years down the line? Additionally, I’m rather clueless about monitor technology and, after some research, it seems I may have to factor more into my budget than $200 for one good enough to display accurate colors and render typography well.



If processing power and memory would be an issue, I could increase the memory of the basic Mini to 8GB for around $60 with aftermarket ram or buy the Mini with a quad-processor and 4GB of ram for $799. Add the $200 (or more) for a monitor and I’m creeping closer to the cost of the new Imac. I’ve all but completely ruled out the purchase of a Macbook Pro (which I desire for it’s portability) because the basic model is comparable to the basic Mini in terms of processing power and $600 more. I’m also considering buying a used machine where I could get a more power for less money.


Any thoughts that may help me come to a decision would be much appreciated.

iMac

Posted on Feb 4, 2013 3:50 PM

Reply
60 replies

Feb 11, 2013 9:23 PM in response to rkaufmann87

So a larger drive has no effect on performance, it just has more capacity than would be used. That makes sense. I'm not trying to clone the internal drive though because it has failed. I simply want to run the machine from an external drive and before I purchase one, I'd first like to test it using a drive that has some information stored on it. Can I install the OS without formatting the drive? Thanks for your help.

Feb 12, 2013 6:54 AM in response to Dr. Benway

Dr. Benway wrote:


So a larger drive has no effect on performance, it just has more capacity than would be used. That makes sense. I'm not trying to clone the internal drive though because it has failed. I simply want to run the machine from an external drive and before I purchase one, I'd first like to test it using a drive that has some information stored on it. Can I install the OS without formatting the drive? Thanks for your help.

None.

Feb 12, 2013 8:08 PM in response to rkaufmann87

Thanks for asking. I certainly have enough information, thanks to everyone who has participated in this discussion, but I haven't made a decision yet. I'm attracted to the Imac because of its performance and affordability but not for the fact that it can't be upgraded post-purchase or opened if a piece of its hardware should fail. I had thought that I could save some money by purchasing the Mini but, after upgrading the ram and purchasing a decent monitor, I'd be spending about the same money as I would on an Imac. For the time being, I'd like to try running my '06 Imac from an external drive. Hopefully the FW400 connection will be adequate until I come to a decision on a new purchase.

Feb 18, 2013 4:14 PM in response to MichelPM

Thanks for your reply. I really don't know much about external drives but was told on another forum that OWC made reputable ones. $105 for a 500GB drive seems like a great price and I think 500GB will be enough space. I did a quick search and found that OS 10.4.1 takes up about 3GB of space as does CS3. I only have about 150GB of additional data.

Mar 2, 2013 3:48 PM in response to MichelPM

Update: I have been running my '06 Imac with the failed internal drive for the past few days booting it from the internal drive in my old Power Mac G4 which is running in target mode. The two machines are connected via Firewire 400. The Imac is very responsive. I've subjected it to my normal workflow without any trouble. I'm now deciding whether to purchase a new external drive to boot from (as I am using a lot of power I think to run the G4 and Imac simultaneously) or to replace the internal drive of the Imac. Are there any issues with sleeping the computer when it is running on system software installed on an external drive?

Advice on purchasing a new computer for print and web design on a budget.

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple ID.