I lost my ipv6 tunneling after a power outage restarted my Airport Extreme, not sure why that triggered things but I traced it to the 7.6.3 update, perhaps that hadn't loaded until the restart. I reverted to 7.6.1 and the ipv6 tunnel worked again, both in automatic mode - http://test-ipv6.com/ gave automatic 7/10 because using 4 -> 6 tunnel, and in manual mode using Hurricane Electric tunnelbroker, which tested at 10/10. I was able to get it working under 7.6.3 after realizing that Airport Utility 5.6 does not update ipv6 delegated prefix, which is the same as ip6 lan address but with the /64 or whatever added to the end. I updated that field using Airport Utility 6.2 and all is good.
I like Utility 5.6 better than 6.2 but in this case it doesn't do the full job. Hope that helps someone!