Well, it's a long story, so I was trying to spare you! LOL!
There are several libraries, each with about 9-10,000 photos and probably 80-90% of them are the same in each library with the remaining photos being unique to each library.
I'm running OS X 10.8.3 and iPhoto 9.4.3 on both an iMac and MBP, as below:
iPhoto Library Manager version 3.8.6 and version 4.0.6.
iMac 27" Late 2009
2.8 GHz Core i7
16 GB RAM
ATI Radeon HD 4850 512 MB
MBP 17" Mid 2010
2.66 GHz Core i7
8 GB RAM
NVIDIA GeForce GT 330M 512 MB
So the problem arose from trying to keep two iPhoto libraries in sync on the two computers in a typical travelers scenario. Eventually, I upload or download pics into the wrong library. In the past, I have used iPhoto Library Manager to rectify this. However, this time I ran in to issues with both versions of iPLM.
I always try a couple of test runs with iPLM, to make sure I have it set correctly. I started with attempting to duplicate a current library via iPLM's Merge into a new, clean, library function. The duplicate detection choices were turned off, as I wanted to duplicate the library, thus testing my settings and the software. However, I did not end up with the same number of photos or events that I started with. I verified the settings and tried different settings and get the same wrong result. I have the same problem using iPLMs rebuild function. Also, I am in communication with the developer and he is addressing from his end, but the back and forth is sometimes slow. I realize he is just one guy and applaud him for his responsiveness. No beef with him at all. I just saw your basic troubleshooting steps and I had not tried those, yet. So that is the background.
Basically, all my libraries are very simple. Everything is organized only by Events. I don't think I have added any keywords and there are no slideshows, photobooks, or greeting cards. What I want to accomplish is to merge the libraries and retain original pic and its descriptive data as it was when I first took the pic. I have never done any serious editing. However, about 2,000 of these pics are modified, as determined by using iPLMs Extract function. I would like to keep any organization into Events that I have done, if possible.
Is there another way to do this just with iPhoto, while iPLM is getting the kinks worked out and especially since I do not have keywords, albums, etc. I would even be willing to buy Aperture, if that would help. I have read that Aperture can be used to merge iPhoto libraries, but am not at all clear on the details. Also, from reading the version history of iPLM's version 4, there have been some pretty serious issues since its release. I don't want to count on something that isn't working only to realize months later that my pics are missing their original date or GPS data or something that might not be obvious at first and with thousands of photos.
Sory this was so long, but now you know the rest of the story and hopefully, can give me some good advice.
Many thanks.
Oops!--I almost forgot! Yes, I have rebooted. Nothing changed. BTW, the number of pics and events discrepancy varies from one rebuild to the next, with the same settings. The developer seems to have provided a fix for that, but I am curious about being able to do this without iPLM, for now, until I'm certain that all of the bugs have been resolved. As I mentioned, kudos to the developer. I'm just wanting an alternative in the meantime.
Message was edited by: jamesfromoakland park