Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

Macbook Air SSD failure?

I've had my MBA for just under a year, and the SSD failed today. I saw the dreaded white screen. I took it into an Apple store, and they are having to replace the SSD. Unfortunately, they didn't have the one I need in stock. So, it will be a few days. I'll be lost without my MBA. LOL


Has anyone else had issues with SSD failure on MBA? I hope this is not a common issue. Luckily, it is still under warrants. The part was about $800.

MacBook Air

Posted on Aug 1, 2013 8:19 PM

Reply
431 replies

Sep 15, 2013 12:06 AM in response to Ognar

Another MBA 2012 SSD failed on me today. My warranty ended last August and was told I have to pay $280 to replace the SSD drive. I am only a student and I have no way of coming up with that kind of money fast. It gave me hope hearing that you were an exception to the strict warranty policy. May I ask how you were able to avail the one time coverage? What should I say when I make the call? I really need help! Thank you.

Sep 15, 2013 4:48 AM in response to PlotinusVeritas

To be fair I don't know the purpose of Apple changing the connector on a standard drive, and there may be a valid reason for them doing so. So let me restate what I wrote: Not being able to complete simple repairs with standard components may turn me off of Apple products. I'm not knocking their quality, and I love that I can access my mac mini rather easily, but I find tinkering with this MBA (It's fixed - typing on it now) a headache.


The repair took Apple a week to complete. Well probably 5 days to get the part, and 15 minutes to pop the drive in ;-)

Sep 15, 2013 11:16 AM in response to Ognar

Ognar

To be fair I don't know the purpose of Apple changing the connector on a standard drive,


micro-sata adapter on the SSD in the Air......reason being a conventional SATA connector would be illogical to place in the ultrathin macbook Air.



There is no "standard" component in almost ALL mfg. of 'ultrabook' style computers. There are countless reasons for same.


Nothing is "repaired" inside the Air, its ... "remove bad/broken part A, toss for recycles......grab new part A and insert"



As a former laptop repair person, the days of "fixing" things inside laptops ended a long time ago. As such there is nothing to "fix" inside the Air, just replace.


Its all... "remove broken....toss it.....insert new"


You should be happy the AIr is so incredibly simple with only one moving part.

Sorry your SSD failed, ....computers break down, however having countless 1000s of laptops thru my hands, the Apple is far superior in build, reliability, etc,,.... as your yourself admit.



And you have to admit from below pic, there is scant little to replace in the Air, far far far less than conventional laptops. 😊


User uploaded file


Sep 15, 2013 2:57 PM in response to ksatterwhite

Here is my survey result asking the failure rate of Macbook Airs in an online community....


I know this is not scientific or well-controlled survey, but hope to give you a rough idea at least about the high failure rate in 2012 model compared to other models.


Reported SSD Failure Issues and Failure Rate


1. Macbook Air 2008 Model: 0 out of 1 (0%)

2. Macbook Air 2009 Model: 0 out of 1 (0%)

3. Macbook Air 2010 Model: 1 out of 14 (7%)

4. Macbook Air 2011 Model: 2 out of 14 (14%)

5. Macbook Air 2012 Model: 10 out of 31 (32%)

6. Macbook Air 2013 Model: 2 out of 26 (8%)



Here is the link to the survey. If you click the "결과보기" button on the page, you can read the survey questions in English though it's a Korean community.

http://cafe.naver.com/inmacbook/879835

Sep 16, 2013 3:05 AM in response to ksatterwhite

Hi All,


I would like to update the latest status of my MBA mid-2012.


After reading through all the posts here, I made a call to the Apple Hotline again and explain my issue. I also mentioned about this topic. The person on the phone asked me to send my MBA to the service shop to confirm again if It's the SSD failure. He gave me his name so I would have to call back him once the investigation is done.


I went to the service shop. The guy confirmed that It's the SSD failure. I called back to the hotline. Finally, they gave me free of charge to change the SSD.


Thanks everyone here for sharing your cases. They are very helpful.


For the people here who are still thinking that the SSD failure is a rare case, please go and talk to any Apple service providers, you will found that there are many failures happened to MBA-2012. SSD is out of stock very places here in Bangkok as well as some other countries.


PS. my case is about 1 month out of warranty.


Regards,

Sep 20, 2013 6:10 PM in response to ksatterwhite

My MacBook Air was purchased 6/2012. While still under warranty, the SSD failed--maybe 6 months ago. Today it happened again. Two SSD failures, on a 15-month-old 13" MacBook Air mid 2012 model. When I spoke to a non-Apple emply who is supposed to be an "expert" in Macs, he said that it is not an uncommon failure.


Is the repair really $800? I was expecting closer to $200.

Sep 20, 2013 6:35 PM in response to j tyson

The problem is that it is strongly suspected that a specific SSD model has much higher failure rate.


Here is another survey's result....


Failure ratio of Toshiba SSD in MBA 2012: 47% (21 out of 44)

Failure ratio of Samsung SSD in MBA 2012: 4% (1 out 26)

....


Ask your expert whether 47% failure ratio can be considered as the "common" phenomena.

Or the difference between 47% and 4%.


http://forums.macrumors.com/showthread.php?t=1633123

Sep 21, 2013 4:53 PM in response to gloostar

gloostar,

Add me to another macbook 5.2 (256gb ssd) failure list. I do think a broader survey is required and we cannot conclude whether the issue is toshiba / samsung - I do think it has something to do with the firmware corrupting the controller. Just a hunch. but a broader survey of this phenomenon is warranted. Interestingly a cluster seems to be happening after august, about a year the macbook air was released.

No conspiracy theories needed - we just need numbers and quickly.

Macbook Air SSD failure?

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple ID.