Csound1 wrote:
It sounds like you have not setup iCloud correctly
On your Mac, open Calendar, go to Preferences>General and tell me what the default calendar is (you'll see it at the bottom of the General page)
Subscribe to the Birthday calendar at iCloud.com, then it will appear on all iCloud clients.
Csound, I do appreciate your taking time to attempt to assist but please trust me I did not start with all this yesterday. In fact I am so old and crotchedy that built myfirst computer bought at Heathkit. 🙂 Like tech always says, it's you not them, I'll take that bet 99 out of 100 it's IS THEM!
The birthdays calendar takes it's information from the contact list. I do not use that feature of the contact list preferring to eliminate the extra step. I simply put a birthday in and set it for posting every year. This works without a problem for YEARS! Now Apple has already agreed and noted that they have that very problem that they have been unable to correct. For some reason, unknow to them as well, the setting of a ANNUAL calendar event simply comes and goes at some whim of the 0's and 1's. Again only on the desktop usually and if they do reappear they do so suddebnly as multiple entries despite only being on my HOME default calendar.
Another reason I donot use such things as a separate birthday calendar is that the process of merging data is where most data is corrupted. Verizon recently merged some of their data and now my first name on an account is also my last name. Two months still trying to get that corrected.
No this is not a settings problem. Often check settings as another wonderful thing in today's age of computing, updates often change them. Not the case here. IT IS THEM and it is understandable that things like this happen. What is not understandable is that they don't routinely cop to the errors and simply report their efforts to correct them. Multi platform sync is probably the hardest thing to do in computing and for most part Apple does it better than anyone. This is why it would be nice to have the manual alternative. Manaul sync not be as magical but it worked.
George in NY