Apple Event: May 7th at 7 am PT

Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

Migration assistant won't work via thunderbolt in Mavericks

I've followed exactly the instructions for doing a migration assistant data transfer via thunderbolt, per this document:


http://support.apple.com/kb/HT5872?viewlocale=en_US


My target computer will not see my source computer via thunderbolt. If I turn on wifi, it will see it, but it says it will take 50+ hours to transfer. I have a thunderbolt cable and two thunderbolt equipped macs running Mavericks (mid 2011 iMac --> late 2013 MBP Retina).


Anyone have any thoughts on a solution?

MacBook Pro with Retina display, OS X Mavericks (10.9)

Posted on Nov 19, 2013 5:09 AM

Reply
51 replies

Feb 29, 2016 6:32 PM in response to Modee

Sadly, they seem to have deleted your excellent response concerning T-bolt-1 vs T-bolt-2. I had no idea there was a change.

I repost your real solution here. It completely corresponds to the experience I had and should be awarded 5 stars!


Migration assistant won't work via thunderbolt in Mavericks

If you have an older Macbook Pro, such as say a 2011 one, even if it has a thunderbolt cable port on it, it will be Thunderbolt 1 standard and will not handshake with a newer MacBook Pro on the Thunderbolt 2 standard. So all these machinations noted above will matter not.


Test it for yourself - hook up the new Mac to a newer Mac both on Thunderbolt 2 and the Migration Assistant handshaking will work right away, including if you start on WiFi and then hook up the cable afterwards - will be instantly recognized.


If you are trying to migrate from an older MacBook pro to a newer one, the best you may hope for is ethernet. Since the newest MacBook Pros do not have ethernet ports, one solution that worked for me is to connect the ethernet cable to the old Macbook Pro, and then connect that ethernet to the thunderbolt port on the new MacBook Pro via an ethernet to thunderbolt adapter, such as the Apple Thunderbolt to Gigabit Ethernet Adapter MD463LL/A.


Another solution is to do a time machine backup of the older Mac, and then do the migration from that backup. This is also quite a bit faster than simply transferring the data from the old MacBook Pro itself, straight across WiFi.


Transferring say 500 Gb of data from the older Mac to the newer Mac via WiFi alone, will take 3 - 5 days, and may be unreliable besides since packets of information may be missed. Via ethernet will take about 8 hours (Thunderbolt just a couple of hours, but as noted above, not an option).


So don't your waste your time with all of the above "tricks" people have written about if you have a Thunderbolt 1 machine - it will not handshake with a Thunderbolt 2 machine directly.

Feb 29, 2016 10:10 PM in response to John Zwiebel

Thanks John Zwiebel for restoring my original post! (Definitely better than just the word "okay" :-).


One more thing - I suggest forgetting about handling the fire vault encryption at the same time as the data migration. Even with an ethernet cable between the 2011 MacBook Pro and the new MacBook Pro, trying to get both jobs done at once just left me hanging for a couple of days with no finale. So just handle your data transfer - and then encrypt for FileVault later. (Uncheck the boxes in the Migration Assistant set up process that ask you if you want to encrypt for Firevault at the same time as migration of data.)

May 18, 2016 9:15 AM in response to John Zwiebel

Maybe I misunderstood your post but after having problems trying to use my thunderbolt cable to work between my old 2011 MacBook Pro and a new one I understood it to mean it wasnt possible. I decided to go the Ethernet route so I got them connected went through the migration assistant setup ...again and was relieved at least something was working. The status was showing time remaining around eight hours (350 gbs) when suddenly the connection switched from Ethernet to thunderbolt, I had forgotten to remove the thunderbolt cable. One hour later and it's finished. Just wanted to post this in case someone else might assume the thunderbolt cable wouldn't work on a 2011 Mbp.

Aug 16, 2016 2:07 PM in response to jlwaters

I'm just about to buy a new MBP and have been getting different opinions from Apple support regarding using Thunderbolt, Thunderbolt 2 or USB/C Thunderbolt for migration assistant. After watching someone onYouTube actually successfully migrate between a 2011 MB air and a 2015 MB air I'm convinced a change somewhere, possibly in OSX El Capitan now allows this to take place.


So does anyone know conclusively if it is possible to migrate to a 2015 Mac Book with the usb/C input for thunderbolt from a 2012 MBP which has original Thunderbolt?

Migration assistant won't work via thunderbolt in Mavericks

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple ID.