Apple Intelligence is now available on iPhone, iPad, and Mac!

Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

Motorola Surfboard 5101 Cable Modem

I just wanted to post a message about my findings and my solution to the Mototrola SurfBoard 5101 Cable modem. I use comcast as my ISP. I was using an old COM21 modem. I was getting around 4300 KBPS on a broadband test from Speakeasy. Since Comcast was starting this PowerBoost, I needed a DOCSIS 1.1 compliant modem and the COM21 modem wasn't. I went to my localComcast office to switch it out since I was leasing one. They gave me a SurfBoard 5101. I already saw the postings and the articles on Macfixit.com. I tried the modem and was getting 2700 Kbps. I tried everything to get the speed better. Connecting my iMac directly to the modem. Tweaking TCP settings.

I called Comcast and they said they never heard of the issue. I explained of all the postings I saw and the artiles also. She said she believed me but didn't know of the problem. I found one article talking about using other modems. The newer Surfboard 5120 modem said was better but had issues with Comcast's network and would disconnect. They said the linksys cable modem wasn't any better. The one they said was the best was the DLINK DCM-202. It was 49.95 on sale at Best Buy. I thought, what the **, I'll try it. If it didn't work I can return it. I got it home. Installed it. Provisioned it and ran the Speakeasy tests. I was blown away. I got a speed of 9049 Kbps. Just ran the test while typing this.

So if anyone else having this issue, I would return the cable modem back to Comcast and ask for a non Motorola modem. That's the advice the Comcast rep told me. Or just buy the DLINK modem. I can now return the 5101 modem and stop leasing it and finally I get my full speed.

Thanks!!!

iMac 17" G5 iSight and iBook G4; iPod 5G, Mac OS X (10.4.7), Airport Express (Used for iTunes)

Posted on Aug 17, 2006 4:40 PM

Reply
4 replies

Aug 17, 2006 7:34 PM in response to The hatter

I couldn't believe it either!!! For over 2 years I have been running at the slower speed when using the COM21 modem. At least with that modem I was get betwenn 4 and 5 megabits.

I tested the TCP settings mentioned with the new DLINK modem and it didn't make a difference one way or the other.

One thing I did notice on DLINK's web site when I went to check to see if there were fimrware upgrades, was a special upgrade for Comcast users.

"Firmware 2.0.1 ¤ This firmware upgrade is for Comcast users only.8/18/2004"

It dosen't say what the firmware fixes for it but I guess it really did something according to all of my tests. I wonder how many other people out there are having the same issue and don't realize it is the cable modem.


iMac 17" G5 iSight and iBook G4; iPod 5G Mac OS X (10.4.6) Airport Express (Used for iTunes)

Aug 17, 2006 8:09 PM in response to The hatter

I did some more research into this and see what anyone out there thinks. The Dlink modem uses a TI chipset with a method of controlling ACKS called Turbodox. It does ACK filtering. I also have read the the newer Motorola Sufboard modem (5120) works fine with Macs. This modem also uses TurboDox.

If you run a tweak test from DSLREPORTS.COM, it states to turn on selective ACKS. Selective ACKS is an option in OS X. Delayed ACKS are. I have tried the delayed ACKS on my iMac with the 5101 but didn't have any luck. I noticed also a person mentioned in the macfixit.com article said he thought the delayed acks setting helped his issue.

I am wondering if the TurboDox is taking care of this "selective acks" setting at the modem level instead of the machine level. Since the Macs can't do this the modem does and the connection is much faster.

I found a white paper on the TurboDox implementation and what it does with ACKS:

http://focus.ti.com/lit/ml/spay014/spay014.pdf

iMac 17" G5 iSight and iBook G4; iPod 5G Mac OS X (10.4.7) Airport Express (Used for iTunes)

Motorola Surfboard 5101 Cable Modem

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.