MacBook Pro Repeatedly Loads Purple & Teal Stripe, Gray, Light Blue, Bright Blue and Bright Blue Stripe Screens Instead of OS after Optical Drive Replacement by Apple (PICTURES INCLUDED)

User uploaded file

17 inch March 26-29 (order date – shipping date) 2011 MacBook Pro, 256GB Solid State Drive, 2.3 GHz Quad-core Intel Core i7, 1 processer, 4 Cores, 256 KB L2 Cache per core, 8 MB L3 Cache, 8 GB Memory (8GB 1333MHZ DDR3 SDRAM - 2X4GB), AMD Radeon HD 6750M Video Card, Intel HD Graphics 3000 with 512 MB total of VRAM. 110 GBs of free/unused disk space remaining.


Full Specs are in subsequent post.


The issues described in the title continue even after I’ve reinstalled the operating system twice (Snow Leopard) and installed Mavericks (which is working fine and even faster). I’ve tried many commands to repair this.


If anyone has experienced any of the symptoms above or below, your advice and response will be much appreciated as well as marked. These are the details:


My Early 2011 MacBook Pro has had the typical blue screens, screen freezes and graphics issues since I bought it about three years ago but nothing like this and NEVER any load issues until about a month ago. That was when my superdrive replacement was put in.


Since then my MacBook Pro will go into hard freezes or kernel panics. Then I’ll have to power it down manually and power it up manually. It’ll then refuse to load the OS until after multiple tries. It started out just 2 or 3, then 4 or 5, then 6-12, then 20. Now it takes over 30 boots to load the OS. These boot issues also occur even if it doesn’t freeze, i.e.: when I shut it down or restart it naturally (via the Apple menu, etc.).


95% of the time it’ll load to a gray screen instead of the OS. 4% of the time it’ll load to a light blue screen. Then there are the others: the first time this happened it loaded to the striped purple and teal screen shown in the picture. This happened the next four times then intermittently for about 5 or so more times.


It also loaded gray flickering screens. Flickering screens also occurred right before it froze and had to be manually powered down and up. Then it began to load regular gray and light blue screens and all flickering screens stopped. And then bright blue screens a couple times intermittently for a few days, sometimes with lines. Sometimes it’ll load to a blank/black screen as well. I’d reset the NVRAM and SMC but it still continued, happening multiple times a day, each time taking more and more hard shut downs and hard power ons to finally load the OS.


Until I installed Mavericks, every time it finally loaded the OS Finder began indexing. After Mavericks this has occurred 95% of the time.


After talking to Apple Support they had me do a NVRAM and SMC reset again over the phone. The MacBook Pro refused to load the entire time we were on the phone. After the call it got worse. It froze over 6 times that day and at worse took over 30 boots to load the OS.


I finally had time to deal with it the next day when it froze again. After over 25 boots it loaded and I put in the Snow Leopard OS dvd and ran Disk Utility. I verified the hard drive and it said it was fine. Repaired the disk anyway and it gave this message at the end:


“Updating boot support partitions for volume required”.


Next I tried to start in safe mode and it just hung up for hours. Then started up in single mode and it loaded the OS. It then loaded normally for three times in a row. I reinstalled Snow Leopard. Everything loaded normally. I waited an hour or so and then I downloaded Mavericks. 5 or so hours later Mavericks was installed. Everything hardware wise was fine for a day and all software issues were easily fixable incompatibilities. My Mac was even faster with Mavericks. However, Photoshop did give a perhaps relevant message:


“Photoshop has encountered a problem with the display driver, and has temporarily disabled GPU enhancements. Check the video card manufacturer’s website for the latest software.


GPU enhancements can be enabled in the Performance panel of Preferences.”


(I have OpenGL enabled in Photoshop and it was already checked when this error occurred).



Two days ago I went to Disk Utility to repair permissions while logged in to a non-admin account. Verified and repaired the disk, then verified permissions. Everything fine. After repairing permissions however, it gave a weird error box:


"Unapproved caller, SecurityAgent may only be invoked by Apple software".


The box stayed “stuck” in the Disk Utility window. My MacBook Pro then failed to do anything. I manually powered it down and up. It loaded to a gray screen with the error message box again: "Unapproved caller, SecurityAgent may only be invoked by Apple software".


It then refused to load anything else but this message box on a gray screen even after rebooting it multiple times in safe, verbose and single modes and after resetting the NVRAM and SMC. I went online with an iPad and entered in the error and got some advice. I tried to run fsck and erase the /var/folders/ via single user mode but it still loaded to a gray screen with the error message. I just decided to skip to the end and Cmd-R loaded into recovery mode and reinstalled Mavericks again. That worked: the message has not appeared since.


Some people have said this error is related to a hard drive cable failure. I know that this cable was tampered with during the optical drive replacement procedures because I watched them do it.


Everything was fine for a day. Then yesterday my MacBook Pro froze while trying to open a VLC file. It took 12 boots to load the OS. I tried single mode once and verbose mode once. 10 times it loaded to gray screens, even in those mode. A Safe boot lead to a bright blue screen. Finally reset the SMC and it loaded on the 12th time.


Just five hours ago the same thing happened except it took over 30 boots to load the OS. Single, verbose and normal boots, NVRAM and SMC resets lead to gray screens. Safe boots lead to bright blue screens with and without lines (see pictures). Finally loaded on a normal boot.


I know I should have tried safe booting, verbose, single and recovery modes, disk utility, fsck and other command methods earlier this month but in the end, these methods have not solved the problem anymore than resetting the NVRAM or SMC.


There seems to be conclusive evidence that it’s a hardware problem, stemming from last month, the FIRST AND ONLY time my MacBook Pro was opened up. Maybe it’s the hard drive cable, but it could also be the graphics card and/or logic board (something that’s always been defective on this MacBook Pro, in my opinion). Many early 2011 MacBook Pro owners have given evidence to the latter possibility online.


The first time it started it seemed to stem from me using iPhoto and Photoshop a lot. I had both running continuously for about two weeks. This is another reason for suspecting the graphics card/logic board is at fault (in addition to three years of screen/graphics glitches). And since the card is soldered to the board and the board connected to the cable...I also have serious battery draining issues, something else that got bad after the Apple Superdrive repair. And the battery is connected to the board...


Also, since downloading Mavericks, windows from every app get blurry/fuzzy when I scroll or zoom in. I have read that this is happening to a lot of folks though for various reasons.


I guess it could always be the hard drive. I just don’t know. I’m taking it in to Apple, but can't right away because it’s not local. I know they’ll be able to run a test on the hard drive. I wanted to see if anyone else has had this problem (especially the purple and teal striped screen) before they start poking around, possibly creating another problem that goes beyond my Apple Care Plan allotment.






User uploaded file

User uploaded file

Posted on Jun 24, 2014 3:59 PM

Reply
16 replies

Jun 24, 2014 4:05 PM in response to SameMacDifferentDay

SPECS OF MY MACBOOK PRO:

Model Name: March 26-29 2011 MacBook Pro (order date – shipping date)

Model Identifier: MacBookPro8,3

Processor Name: Quad-core Intel Core i7

Processor Speed: 2.3 GHz

Number of Processors: 1

Total Number of Cores: 4

L2 Cache (per Core): 256 KB

L3 Cache: 8 MB

Memory: 8 GB Memory (8GB 1333MHZ DDR3 SDRAM - 2X4GB)

HARD DRIVE: 256GB Solid State Drive

DISPLAY: MBP 17" HR Antiglare WS Display


AMD Radeon HD 6750M:


Chipset Model: AMD Radeon HD 6750M

Type: GPU

Bus: PCIe

PCIe Lane Width: x8

VRAM (Total): 1024 MB

Vendor: ATI (0x1002)

Device ID: 0x6741

Revision ID: 0x0000

ROM Revision: 113-C0170L-573

gMux Version: 1.9.24

EFI Driver Version: 01.00.573


Intel HD Graphics 3000:


Chipset Model: Intel HD Graphics 3000

Type: GPU

Bus: Built-In

VRAM (Total): 512 MB

Vendor: Intel (0x8086)

Device ID: 0x0126

Revision ID: 0x0009

gMux Version: 1.9.24


Displays

Color LCD:

Resolution: 1920 x 1200

Pixel Depth: 32-Bit Color (ARGB8888)

Main Display: Yes

Mirror: Off

Online: Yes

Built-In: Yes


Battery Information:


Model Information:

Serial Number: C01111403GLDGKMAE

Manufacturer: DP

Device Name: bq20z451

Pack Lot Code: 0000

PCB Lot Code: 0000

Firmware Version: 0406

Hardware Revision: 0001

Cell Revision: 1102

Charge Information:

Charge Remaining (mAh): 4583

Fully Charged: No

Charging: Yes

Full Charge Capacity (mAh): 7765

Health Information:

Cycle Count: 276

Condition: Normal

Battery Installed: Yes

Amperage (mA): -4487

Voltage (mV): 11306


System Power Settings:


AC Power:

System Sleep Timer (Minutes): 15

Disk Sleep Timer (Minutes): 10

Display Sleep Timer (Minutes): 15

Wake on AC Change: No

Wake on Clamshell Open: Yes

Wake on LAN: No

Current Power Source: Yes

Display Sleep Uses Dim: No

GPUSwitch: 2

Battery Power:

System Sleep Timer (Minutes): 15

Disk Sleep Timer (Minutes): 10

Display Sleep Timer (Minutes): 5

Wake on AC Change: No

Wake on Clamshell Open: Yes

Display Sleep Uses Dim: No

GPUSwitch: 2

Reduce Brightness: Yes


Hardware Configuration:


UPS Installed: No


AC Charger Information:


Connected: Yes

ID: 0x0100

Wattage (W): 85

Revision: 0x0000

Family: 0x0085

Serial Number: 0x007ad8c5

Charging: Yes


Current operating system: 10.9.3 (Mavericks) ; Installed on 6/21/14

Previous operating system: 10.6.8 (Snow Leopard); Installed 4/4/11

Reinstalled multiple times. Last reinstall: 6/21/14

Jun 24, 2014 4:14 PM in response to Barry Hemphill

Thanks for such a quick reply. Yes, I will be taking your advice :-).


Might be two weeks away though so...Also worried they won't really discover or focus on the real issues. I'm already kinda skating on ice with my Apple Care Plan. I need the computer on all the time and so can't have this happening again after they "repair" it. That's why I have turned to the web where there's so much more educational resources than what I have received from Apple thus far.


Thanks again :-)

Jun 24, 2014 4:27 PM in response to SameMacDifferentDay

I forgot to mention in my post:


About three weeks ago, while taking pictures of the purple and teal stripe screen, three mid-tone beeps kept repeating from the right side of my MacBook Pro. It didn't stop for two minutes until I powered it down. This has only occurred once, ever. I have never installed any ram.

Any and all additional advice will be welcome.

Jun 27, 2014 12:43 PM in response to SameMacDifferentDay

Thanks Andy-J-D!! I just tried to give you props right now but MacBook Pro was acting up and I accidentally clicked on my own post (arrrggg). I'm a forum newbie but I just asked if that can be removed (Can I remove points given accidentally for "this answered my question"). I don't deserve a point yet!! If not I might just make a new post.


I think its the problem too. Photoshop gave me the same message about the GPU and I had some backlight issues today. Mac shut down itself and then screen was really dark while loading, wouldn't load for a while...Read somewhere it might be the thermal paste on the graphics card. I hope its not like a billion things.


I will post back here with what is wrong after the visit so others can be helped.

Jun 27, 2014 1:13 PM in response to SameMacDifferentDay

I wonder if I can get the points back to give them to the person who really DOES solve this issue...anyway...

No, you cannot (no one can) "un-ring the bell."

Points, to some of us anyway, are not terribly important. Their main use is supposed to be for people reading posts (more points, at least theoretically, indicate good advice over time) to assess the quality of the feedback. Having said that, I (and virtually everyone else) has given less than useful information.

Barry

Jun 27, 2014 3:51 PM in response to Barry Hemphill

Yeah, well believe me everything said here has helped. I paid over $3600 for this Mac and its only been three years so I'm not too happy about this. So hearing any helpful feedback helps.


My G4 is still ticking...I really didn't want to buy a laptop but needed to and figure I'd just get the best. Well the first time I tried to do anything graphics heavy (Photoshop, iPhoto) and this happens. I've not used FaceTime, Skype, etc. not played any video games. I've watched hardly any movies, or used photo software that much until now.


I did find a 430 page post about 2011 MacBook Pros and GPU issues at 2011 MacBook Pro and Discrete Graphics Card . I will be taking it in to any subsequent visit. I don't intend to ever pay for this issue and whatever I have to do to make sure of that, I will.

Jul 3, 2014 7:53 PM in response to SameMacDifferentDay

This is EXACTLY what my 2011 MacBook Pro us doing! Right now, I'm looking at a blank bright blue screen. It won't respond to commands. I can't get the CD currently in it to eject so that I can tarty a disk repair with my CD. I've restarted it about 30 times. My AppleCare warranty expired in March. Just before it did, I had to get the main logic board replaced for vertical pink lines in the screen and other issues with the display. That resolved the issue until last week. I don't know what the warranty on the logic board is...if it's just 90 days (in which case I'm screwed) or if it is one year like most of their hardware products are. I don't know what to do. I've done all the same things you did. I have been a happy apple customer since the very beginning, but I definitely think there is a fault with this model.

Jul 4, 2014 2:13 PM in response to Lisa Manus

I'd try to argue that the card they put in is defective. There's no way that it isn't if this is occurring 90 days later. They put in a dud. You have so many grounds, I'd forget about worrying about the length of the warranty. Go back and tell them that they put in a defective card and that you're not paying for their poor attempt to extort more money from you. This is a graphics card issue and its been proven to be so. You can find a lot of information in the post I linked with my other reply: MacBook Pro and Discrete Graphics Card .


There's a page (at least one!) somewhere in one of the almost 450 pages of discrete GPU complaints that has the same lines we both had on our screens. I saw it the other day but I don't know where, there's so many pages! Tons more like that on the web. Maybe you can take this evidence with you.


Everyone should argue that this should be fixed for free. They have nothing to lose. I notated everything with my MacBook Pro since I got it. It started the moment I began to use Photoshop and iPhoto a lot - for a month. I did not use an external monitor, FaceTime, Skype, video game, or even watch that many videos for three years before then. The minute I used the card a little for a month it died. This means these cards just are unsuitable for this machine.


I'm not even worrying about the cost. I'm simply not paying it and I'm not rushing to the Apple store in some frenzy, spending $$ to travel far away so they can lock up my Mac for days "trying to figure out what's wrong", or ship it away to Xenu. I have other things to do and I didn't pay $4k for that. If they don't just switch out the card right then and there I'll simply threaten to sue and bring up every law from every nationality in my family. They need to have these cards in stock at every Apple store for quick and easy replacements considering the frequency of this problem. Everyone knows what's wrong so they should drop the crap.

I think more people should be like this instead of so easily opening up their pocket book to pay for this crime. It’s unacceptable for any one of us to be anything more than chill. There's enough evidence to the fact that there's a problem with these cards. Even for those that are not under warranty in some form, or not had their MacBook Pros examined and deemed defective GPU wise, there's enough evidence on the web for them to make the case for a free replacement if they just argue the case to Apple Support and every Apple store they can. People need to stop losing money to this obvious and blatant fraud.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

MacBook Pro Repeatedly Loads Purple & Teal Stripe, Gray, Light Blue, Bright Blue and Bright Blue Stripe Screens Instead of OS after Optical Drive Replacement by Apple (PICTURES INCLUDED)

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.