having just purchased my lovely new Hengedock Horizontal I was frustrated to find that cooling was abominable with the clamshell closed and it doesn't look like there was any attempt to try and force additional air around the base (although form what I've read here it doesn't seem to work anyways).
Thanks for the magnet workaround - it's gone down a treat. Not being sure where to find small, powerful magnets, I had a brainwave and grabbed my MagSafe 1-2 adapters from Apple. I found one wasn't enough o trip the sensor, but 2 is. They need to be "upside down" which is to say the MagSafe2 connecter facing upwards. Placed roughly 2/3rd of the way down the left hand speaker and the internal display is switched off. Agree, it's something that Apple should enable in Display Preferences if possible.
The whole reason for doing this was power/cooling/longevity/noise - so what's the ideal setup?
Test system: 3x HP ZR2440w 1900x1200 displays, MBPR 15" mid-2012 with GeForce GPU set to auto switch, clamshell OPEN is a room of roughly 24 degrees C ambient temp
Here's what I've learned
- with 1 external display, (TB/DP) the GPU package draws roughly 0.21A (according to iStatMenus) - fan speed ~2000RPM
- with 2 external displays, (TB/DP+TB/DP OR HDMI) the GPU package draws roughly 0.41A (according to iStatMenus) - fan speed ~2200RPM
- with 3 external displays the GPU package jumps to 1.2A, the resultant spike in GPU core drives the fans up to ~3500RPM
- with 4 displays (3 external plus the internal) the GPU jumps marginally to 1.3A and the fans hit roughly ~3700RPM
* i didn't allow a lot of time for components to "settle" between tests and to be fair, I wasn't running anything in the way of "serious" apps although TimeMachine kicked in part way through the test at the same time as fan speeds quickly reached 4200RPM giving me the sense that with 3-4 displays the tolerances for additional thermal stress with increasing workloads is marginal and the cooling system as a whole was stressed.
All of this still compares favourably to running the system CLOSED where fan speeds rarely dropped below 6500RPM
Conclusions
- the best outcome from a thermal stress and noise standpoint is to run your laptop as a laptop with it's own internal display! :-)
- if like me you need/want more display real-estate, then 2 external displays appears the ideal compromise between ergonomics, flexibility and thermal stress
- whatever you do, run it open (magnets are your friend, remember your Macbook is already FULL of them and is DESIGNED to have them in close proximity at certain points on the chassis, just don't go overboard)
Next steps
I'd like to learn how more modern MBPR 15" systems respond with their more powerful and I would hope, more efficient, embedded and discrete graphics chipsets. If anyone has the time to run a similar test, it would be great to know if it's time for an upgrade :-) (any excuse to convince my wife that it's time!)