Eyeballer001 wrote:
I’m afraid you haven’t convinced me with your arguments. As I see it, modern operating systems are so complicated that it’s not realistic for any individual or even group of individuals to anticipate *every* possible scenario the OS will deal with. It is not rare for even small, seemingly innocuous updates to have unexpected consequences and dysfunctions.
The crux of your argument seems to be that since Bluetooth device pairing with iPhone OS 8.1.1 works for most people in general, and for you in particular, then it is inconceivable that iOS 8.1.1 is at fault for those few outliers having problems.
I think a relevant analogy is the WiFi problem which previously surfaced with OS X Yosemite. Most people had no problems with WiFi after updating. Applying your reasoning would suggest that the WiFi hardware manufacturers were at fault for those few individuals who did have problems. However, in some posted cases, people were having problems connecting Apple computers with Apple Airport stations, both of which had the latest software/firmware updates. Apple finally released a software update which fixed the problem for most affected people. The problem, in a simple sense, was that Apple developers hadn’t accounted for some less common, particular system configurations, and those particular configurations “broke” the WiFi component of Yosemite.
For the other posters in this thread, their devices worked with previous versions of iOS as well as other devices’ implementation of Bluetooth (e.g. Android). That would suggest that the devices had properly implemented some version of Bluetooth. Bluetooth is a common standard, like 802.11n for WiFi, and is maintained by the Bluetooth Special Interest Group. All licensed Bluetooth devices are required to be backwards compatible with older versions of Bluetooth, and so your assertion that users needed to update their device firmware is flawed. Even if Apple had implemented a “new and improved” version of Bluetooth, they would have been required to have it compatible with older devices. (Out of curiosity, how would you suggest I update the Jabra Drive firmware…the device has no mechanism for doing so, nor should it need one given the backwards compatibility requirement for Bluetooth).
If you cannot concede the possibility the Apple messed up, then we’ll just have to agree to disagree.
Cheers
There's always that possibility.
But critical thinking & analysis, combined with basic troubleshooting techniques, common sense and years of experience in the field, along with personal exposure to the devices, leads me to the most reasonable conclusion: Any individual Bluetooth accessory that doesn't work with iOS 8.1.1 or 8.1.2 (assuming other Bluetooth accessories do work) is at fault, and needs to be inspected more closely.
And additionally, since I know for a fact, having worked with accessory manufacturers in the past, that some of those engineers don't place as high of an importance on what they view as 'secondary' issues, things get put on the back burner, and they don't finish coding the updates in a timely manner. Same thing for some email providers. After every major iOS update, there are email providers (usually smaller ones, not the big ones) that had months to get ready, but they didn't. And I have to contact them to light a fire to get them to do so.
And as far as the backwards compatibility part? That's for the most basic functions, i.e. the actual connection. Do the devices see each other and have a basic connection? Yes? Then the backwards compatibility is valid. Anything more advanced does sometimes require firmware updates.
And it's not just Apple that talks about Bluetooth firmware updates:
http://support.apple.com/kb/dl889
http://www8.garmin.com/support/download_details.jsp?id=1528
http://worldwide.bose.com/downloads/en/web/bose_bluetooth_system_download/page.h tml
http://www.alpine-europe.com/index.php?id=1422&L=2