Random order slides in Photos slideshow ?

Is it possible to have slides displayed in random order in a slideshow made with Photos app ?

Photos-OTHER, OS X Yosemite (10.10.3), 15 inch screen

Posted on Apr 10, 2015 7:58 AM

Reply
49 replies

Jun 17, 2016 8:30 AM in response to LuvMe,LuvMyiPod

I believe that the site you link to contains only updaters and they will require that you have an previous installation of iPhoto from DIsk and not the App Store.


If you are running either Yosemite or El Capitan then you will need the iPhoto v9.6 or v9.6.1 updates, these can only be accessed via the App Store


Therefore I'm not sure that your solution will work.

Jun 18, 2016 9:17 AM in response to Archipel Boréal

This Apple Script will shuffle a list of selected photos in Photos and present them as an instant slideshow in a random order:


set ReadFromAlbum to false


on getCurrentSelection()

tell application "Photos"

set imageSel to {}

try

set imageSel to (get selection)

on error errTexttwonumbererrNumtwo

display dialog "Cannot get the selection: " & errNumtwo & return & errTexttwo

end try

return imageSel

end tell

end getCurrentSelection


on getPhotosInAnAlbum()

set PhotoDropBoxName to "PhotoDropBox" -- the name of an album at the top level of the library

tell application "Photos"

if existscontainerPhotoDropBoxName then

set myContainer to containerPhotoDropBoxName



--display dialog "TopLevel variable set"

else

display dialog "Album 'PhotoDropBox' doesn't exist. Please create an album called 'PhotoDropBox' and try again - Exiting" buttons ¬

"OK" with iconcautiondefault button "OK"

return

end if

set myCount to count of media items in myContainer


if (myCount = 0) then

display dialog "The PhotoDropBox album is empty. Please add some photos." as text

return

else

display dialog "About to process " & myCount & " item(s) in PhotoDropBox album" as text

return every media item of myContainer

end if


end tell


end getPhotosInAnAlbum


if (ReadFromAlbum) then

set thephotos to getPhotosInAnAlbum() -- get a list of photos from the album "PhotoDropBox"

else

set thephotos to getCurrentSelection()

end if


set nitems to (count of thephotos)

if (nitems > 1) then

repeat nitems times --shuffle the photos in the list

set split to random number (nitems - 2) + 1


if (split < 1) then

set split to 1

end if


if split is 1 then

set head to {}

set tail to items 2 thru nitems of thephotos

end if


if split is nitems then

set head to items 1 thru (nitems - 1) of thephotos

set tail to {}

end if


if (split > 1) and (split < nitems) then

set head to items 1 thru (split - 1) of thephotos as list

set tail to items (split + 1) thru nitems of thephotos as list

end if

set thephotos to head & tail & (itemsplit of thephotos as list)

end repeat

end if



tell application "Photos"



start slideshowusingthephotos as list

end tell


--return thephotos



I tried, but it does not seem to be possible to create a shuffled album. When I add a photo to an album from a script, it will always be sorted by date. The scripting support in Photos is still limited.

Jul 8, 2016 12:44 PM in response to Archipel Boréal

Its July of 2016 - Still the answer is No there is still no way to have random order slideshow in Photos. I'm guessing photos has been available for 1.5 to 2 years now and as I understand even in the upcoming version of macOS there is still no "random option" for slideshow (I was hopeful, really hopeful it would appear in this update - if it doesn't make it this time, I think it might never appear). I'm still using iPhoto primarily for this reason and when Apple finally makes iPhoto stop working my next stop at this point will be an Adobe product that I would guess has random slideshow capability, like any photo program should (not Photos). I certainly certainly certainly certainly hope that a random option for slideshow will make its appearance (reappearance) in macOS sierra! Its just amazing to me that something like "Memories" and the complexity I assumed that goes into making something like that would appear before we get the fundamental/blocking and tackling of a photo program - random slideshow capability. I have said it before, this is the kind of little thing that would not happen under Steve Jobs leadership reign, maybe for a very short time. I don't know if it was him personally or if it was his driven expectations of making software that was Great and Engineers took it to heart but this would not happen back then, not for this long. Apple you guys are brilliant, you have made some software that does absolutely amazing things that we need and you often made it do it before we even knew we wanted it (my most recent discovery of how amazing you are is is the Multi-Cam capability of Final Cut Pro - Kudos!) but this ommission of Slideshow capability takes away from your greatness. Please! Thank you!

Aug 13, 2016 2:20 AM in response to Archipel Boréal

Hi! Let me add my vote to the "please bring back shuffle mode" list (and while we're at it: the ability to set slide delay in ScreenSaver, the ugly .plist fix seems to be unavailable now due to new security restrictions). Currently, emotions are running high in the family ("why do you claim that the Mac is so much better when I can do this on my PC and you can't?"); it would be great for our collective blood pressure levels and the health of our china if this could be solved.

Best regards

Ulf, Mac nerd since 1985

Dec 23, 2016 10:18 PM in response to Yer_Man

I read what you wrote, and I have decades of designing software to understand the difference between critical features and needless complexity. There is also a difference between software that can hold your hand when you need it, and software that refuses to let go of it.
I understand what iPhoto is, also what Photos is. iPhoto is nearly the pinnacle of mediocrity when it comes to software with a horrid user interface and very limited usefulness. Photos not only lacks that small amount of usefulness, but forces itself on you, so that you have to go to great lengths to disable it so that it doesn't get in your way every time you try to read photos off of a memory card into a useful photo processing program.

Dec 23, 2016 11:19 PM in response to elllarsee_backup_account

If photos does not have this feature then that confirms its status as a completely useless waste of disk space.

Have you ever looked at the size of Photos in the Finder? With just 56.8 MB it is as small as a single RAW image. Photos is just a wrapper to calls to system frameworks directly built into the system library. Removingg the Photos.app will not free much disk space.

User uploaded file


Compare this to the gigantic size of iPhoto 9.6.1with its 1.7GB.

Dec 23, 2016 11:51 PM in response to elllarsee_backup_account

"wat den Eenen sin Uhl, is den Annern sin Nachtigall" as we are saying in my home town.

As a person experienced in software engineering and a power user you are clearly not the target audience for Photos and neither was iPhoto. Neither of both apps are a replacement for a professional tool like Aperture, that I love.

But I can appreciate the design of Photos for a user group, that simply wants to share photos and touch them up a bit, and wants a user interface that makes all basic tasks automatic. It makes it very easy for users who do not want to bother about the details, like the timing or sequence of photos in a slideshow. And the user interface on the Mac is very similar to the Photos user interface on an iPhone or iPad.

Only, this automatic way is a nightmare for users who want to be creative and to take control. Any deviation from the predefined ways needs many clicks or is not possible at all. It s horrid to have to fight Photos for simple tasks like copying the title of a photo into the the comment field of a book page. So I keep sending feedback with feature requests.

Apple has relented a bit during the last year. Photos 2.0 is much better than the first version, and for the time being I will use it for my photo libraries. It is the first photo application by Apple that makes it possible to keep the libraries in sync across my Mac.

Dec 24, 2016 12:04 AM in response to elllarsee_backup_account

I read what you wrote


And yet you didn't understand it. Try again. Your critical feature is my needless complexity and vice versa. Remember there are more usage scenarios than yours alone.


and I have decades of designing software to understand the difference between critical features and needless complexity


But apparently not enough of a grasp of basic english.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Random order slides in Photos slideshow ?

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.