Hi Bob, how did you decide on replacing the optical drive as opposed to replacing the original internal HDD and leaving the optical in place.
I did not use the DVD. I used it one or twice when I got the 2009 iMac, as that was Snow Leopard days, which came on a DVD, and I may have burned 1 or 2 CD's. But for most of the 5 years I've had the iMac, I have not used the DVD, so it was an easy decision to put the SSD in the DVD slot.
Another factor in my decision was the cost of a replacement 1TB SSD for my hard disk was not cheap. The smaller 480GB SSD I installed was less expensive, and it was more than sufficient for my needs. You needs may be different.
And I did put the DVD in an external enclosure, just in case I did need a DVD (1 year and still haven't plugged in the DVD 😁 ).
The OWC DataDoubler Kit was easy to use.
I have a late-2011 27" iMac that I am going to upgrade form a 2TB HDD to SSD. Ideally, I would like to have one SSD drive to handle it all, but my photo collection too large to allow that even on a 1TB SSD. So I am going to need to do a hybrid of an SSD and the spinning disk. Now what I am confused on is whether to make the existing HD as an external one or the optical drive. What are your thoughts.
If you have USB3 or Thunderbolt, an external disk might be OK. However, a Thunderbolt disk is rather expensive compared to USB disks. However, if all you have is USB2 or Firewire, accessing the external disk is going to be much slower compared to an internal disk.
Also, if I do end up using an SSD for my system files and the spinning HD for my photos, etc. what size SSD would you recommend. Is 1TB overkill and should I be ok with 500GB?
I decided based on cost. Otherwise, choose what makes your life comfortable. A 500'ish GB drive is more than enough for the operating system all applications, and a moderate music library, your documents, etc... You could put your pictures, movies, and if a huge music library on the hard disk which can be just about as big as you like.
Then again, if cost is not the factor, you could replace the DVD with a 1TB SSD, and put another 1TB SSD into the original disk slot.
No matter what you decide, make sure you have 3-2-1 backup.
3 copies of your data on different devices (the original is one copy)
2 different backup formats (protects you from a bug in one backup utility)
1 copy off-site (protects against natural disasters and theft)