hardware encoders - an update?

Hi,

my business involves home videos/movies to dvd transfers. I was keeping fairly busy at it until, for some reason, it exploded and now it's getting insane.

I need a much faster encoding solution for my mpeg2 files. currently, i use bitvice (which i love using and love the quality). i was contemplating buying another mac to help with the processing (maybe a quad g5 or a newer macpro once BV is available for it). BUT, if i can maybe buy a hardware encoder, it might help do the trick and be more cost effective.

my current workflow involves transferring the footage to my macs via tbc correctors/vcrs/camcorders etc...

then i prepare the footate within fcp...sometimes cutting footage out if the clients wants editing. then i output and use BV for the mpeg2..then i import into SP and create the DVDs. I find that people LOVE the stories/chapters and menu features. it helps personalize their DVDs imho.

So, is it feasible to do everything up to the export out of FCP and then, instead of using BV, use an encoder to create the mpeg2s onto my Macs for import into SP? real time would be amazing, but honestly, if i can get even a 1:3 ratio, i'd be a happy camper. these 11 encodes on my G4 and 7 hours on my G5 are killing me 🙂 plus, i could turn around projects faster, thus increasing my bottom line.

OF course, i still want to maintain quality. i know we can buy $20K encoders, but that's out of the question.

i read this post:
http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?messageID=1623698&#1623698

but it's archived so i can't respond or follow up.

any new developments in the world of hardware encoders?

Cheers,
Keebler

G4MDDdual1.25; G5 dual 2.0, Mac OS X (10.3.8)

Posted on Oct 30, 2006 3:46 PM

Reply
20 replies

Nov 25, 2006 1:35 PM in response to Mikey M.

Hi Mikey,

I'm back from vacation and onto this encoder thing again 🙂
I did buy a fastcoder as it was only $100.

BUT, i noticed that it won't handle text titles...have you had experience with this before? I can write my QT or DV file just fine out of fcp, but when i use fastcoder, it either writes a white bar at the top of the mpeg2 or it has another white bar with <Transition> or <use> at the top... when i remove the titles and go with pure footage, it works just fine.

thoughts?

Cheers,
keebler

Nov 25, 2006 2:06 PM in response to Keebler

ok...instead of <use>, it says <cut>

So, i took a small clip of the same footage:
title..then 18 secs of footage
i didn't have a transition before so i added one b/n the title and the footage.

NOW, the title has no white bar and neither does the footage, but b/n both, as the transition happens, there is a white bar which briefly displays saying <transition>

ugh

Dec 12, 2006 8:33 AM in response to Mikey M.

Hi Mikey,

Hope all is well. i have an issue with my fastcoder not recording editing footage very well.

When you use your fastcoder, are you using edited footage from within FCP? if so, any issues? i'm getting white bars with messages at the top anytime i use footage with text titles or transitions. any footage that is unedited transfers fine.

any thoughts?
Cheers,
keebler

Dec 16, 2006 10:19 PM in response to Roger Andersson

Cinemacraft is probably one of the best encoder on the market right now. Their top of the line hardware ( 60K and up ) are used by some of the top hollywood authoring house. They also have a cheaper software version. It gives you excellent picture quality and runs fairly fast, 2 to 3 x real time. It runs on any Win desktop ( of course the faster the better ). I know a few people are running it with the new MacPro with boot camp and WinXP.
I own a Sonic Solution Sd2000 hardware encoder. This set up cost me close to 40K four years ago...now, with cinemacraft and a cheap PC, i get the same quality encode...that's pretty amazing, considering CinemaCraft SP2 and a PC would run you about $ 3500.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

hardware encoders - an update?

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.