Is it just me or is voice to text getting worse?

Maybe 18 months to 2 years ago I can remember using voice to text and feeling like it translated 90 to 95% of my sentences correctly. Now, when I dictate a sentence, it is very rare for voice to text to translate it correctly. One of the things I've noticed is voice to text will add pronouns my sentences when I haven't said anything. At first I thought maybe I was making little noises that the program was misinterpreting as pronouns, but I have since noticed that it does this even when I'm absolutely sure I haven't made a noise. I think that what's happening is the program will hear a dependent clause and want to make it an independent clause with this subject a verb and a direct object and so add the pronoun either as a subject or direct object. I wonder if the software designers at Apple are doing this on purpose, not to frustrate users, but because they think most people are using it to write simple, declarative sentences.


Also, voice to text will just capitalize random words, especially conjunctions, For no reason I can discern. It just did it!


PS this happens across devices, from my iPhone, to my iPad, To my computer. There's that capitalization bug you again. Also, I swear to God, it just added "you" for no reason.

MacBook Pro (Retina, 13-inch, Mid 2014), iOS 9.2.1

Posted on Feb 1, 2016 8:13 AM

Reply
48 replies

Jan 27, 2018 5:06 AM in response to Mary London

Among other frustrations, when I write a reply and Emma trying to edit it Lola multiple errors it produces I cannot scroll back to the beginning of the message. Did I hear that there was an apple feedback somewhere where company employees actually read text? This is awful. And as you say it’s getting worse. In my case it’s actually changing text and adding profanities After you press send. The capital letters such as in the word ‘after’ above, occur whenever your microphone turns itself off and you have to turn it back on again, the next word is capitalized.

Jan 27, 2018 6:25 PM in response to SallyMJ

Yes it’s horrible; in fact I have given up trying to use it except for very short messages. Not only does it fail to understand my speech (and I use other programs that understand me quite well) but after I get it all set up and press “send”, it changes the text in a byzantine way, even adding profanity! One thing several people have mentioned, the appearance of a capital where it doesn’t belong, is caused when the microphone shuts itself off and you have to restart it, the first letter is always capitalized. After I have dictated this note I cannot scroll back to edit it. Come on Apple— you’re supposed to be an industry leader!

Feb 15, 2018 10:07 AM in response to Budwhite

I have the capitalization problem in spades. It seems to capitalize as a response to taking the time to breathe. It also De- capitalizes on occasion, and the most maddening thing is that it will read write stuff that's perfect just as I hit send. Sometimes the language isn't even allowed on TV.


So how do we get Apple's attention on this? I saw that thank you for it, but I never saw the instructions. Thanks

Feb 19, 2018 7:15 AM in response to Budwhite

I’ve been using dictation for years and lately it’s been so bad I have to tell you! there isn’t an example, I will leave the air I said error into this previous The previous four words were put in after I had dictated was correct, it overwrites what he thinks should be there. This must be a machine learning but who’s the teacher? Machine taking over

Mar 7, 2018 5:58 PM in response to Budwhite

I have been looking for this thread forever, every time I have searched the results were old - like there is never an issue with Apple! I have seen correct sentences transform after I press send, entire paragraphs magically erase and rewrite themselves, text jumps around as it's editing itself even though nothing seems to change. Now it is adding a space before the sentence and highlighting everything just dictated. It capitalizes where it isn't necessary and sometimes will start a sentence with a lower case. It randomly changes the insertion point. And the keyboard sometimes switches to numbers for no reason. I so hate this product and the arrogant way that the problem is always the user's issue and not the bad engineering. With Siri I have had the text of the request be correct and the action be different. It often can't find the correct person. Sometimes a Siri request will correctly transcribe and find the right person, but then open a blank text. It's like there is nobody home. And some of these actions should be able to be done without the internet. You literally can't ask it to dial a contact without good internet, which was something flip phones could do.

Nov 29, 2017 7:55 AM in response to IdrisSeabright

Hello again IdrisSeabright,


I just wanted to say a big thank you to you for taking the time and trouble to look into this issue for me and try to help. I didn't actually know there was an Apple Feedback page as such, so you have also helped me learn something new today!


All these support / discussion pages are a really excellent resource and have provided me with great, easy-to-understand answers to all sorts of Mac-related issues.


Thank you again.


Mary

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Is it just me or is voice to text getting worse?

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.