Is it just me or is voice to text getting worse?

Maybe 18 months to 2 years ago I can remember using voice to text and feeling like it translated 90 to 95% of my sentences correctly. Now, when I dictate a sentence, it is very rare for voice to text to translate it correctly. One of the things I've noticed is voice to text will add pronouns my sentences when I haven't said anything. At first I thought maybe I was making little noises that the program was misinterpreting as pronouns, but I have since noticed that it does this even when I'm absolutely sure I haven't made a noise. I think that what's happening is the program will hear a dependent clause and want to make it an independent clause with this subject a verb and a direct object and so add the pronoun either as a subject or direct object. I wonder if the software designers at Apple are doing this on purpose, not to frustrate users, but because they think most people are using it to write simple, declarative sentences.


Also, voice to text will just capitalize random words, especially conjunctions, For no reason I can discern. It just did it!


PS this happens across devices, from my iPhone, to my iPad, To my computer. There's that capitalization bug you again. Also, I swear to God, it just added "you" for no reason.

MacBook Pro (Retina, 13-inch, Mid 2014), iOS 9.2.1

Posted on Feb 1, 2016 8:13 AM

Reply
48 replies

May 17, 2017 9:42 AM in response to dialabrain

I meant to say this response was unhelpful but it seems to have kept it as a helpful and will not let me undo it? (All dictated of course) as it is so much quicker and more efficient than typing. at least it used to be, now I have to keep going back and correcting the mistakes, and I'm not sure if that is slow or not than typing the words in the first place. So for example for this particular paragraph above I had to make 4 corrections. I think you are right about the microphone as my 2008 MacBook is the worst followed by my 2010 iPad and then my six month old iPhone 6s. So on thinking again I think I shall leave it as a helpful as you did mention the microphone.

Jan 18, 2018 12:42 AM in response to Budwhite

I experienced the same issues after purchasing my iPhone 7 Plus.


I’ve been playing around with my friends phone and it works way better than my Apple devices translations.


Our IP I experienced the same issues after purchasing my iPhone 7 Plus.


I’ve been playing around with my friends phone and it works way better than my Apple devices translations.


RIP Apple


Hello Android


I am one of 1 billion people and what I have to say really doesn’t matter to Apple. But I will admit that I will not purchase garbage anymore. These phones are way too expensive for that. A thousand dollars!

Jan 27, 2018 5:26 PM in response to Budwhite

I KNOW for a fact the dictation on this SE is worse than on the 5C I got four years ago. Just got an SE in October 2017. This newer phone is dumber than the old one. It’s frustrating to use dictation, even though it’s much more officiant, because it makes so many mistakes.


Instead of recognizing some words with several syllables, this phone substitutes 3-4 small words that don’t make any sense together. Whenever I dictate a plural word, this phone always spells it with an apostrophe plus letter s (“‘s”). It rephrases perfectly good sentences so they don’t make sense, changes perfectly good words into other ones, and capitalizes words in the middle of sentences for no rhyme or reason. It’s as if Siri fancies herself an English teacher, always wants to correct me, but her corrections are wrong. I was an English major, and her understanding of spelling and grammar is elementary school level at best.


This is a more expensive phone than my last one. I would think the functions with higher tech iPhones would get better, not worse!

Feb 19, 2018 9:54 AM in response to g bruce

I haven't quite figured out what the voice to text algorithm does, but it's clearly not solely based on word to word translation. It's trying to do something like guess the context of a sentence or phrase and make sense in its own little dictionary, which as often as not isn't even close to the meaning intended. The biggest mystery to me is why corrected text is changed at the last minute, just before it is sent, Into a baroque and profane jargon, so you can’t edit it. This is such an obvious bug that you would think Apple would notice it and eliminate it. But they haven't and they didn't. The other thing that puzzles me about Apple is that even if they choose not to reply to the user discussions, at the very least they ought to let you know that they're

reacting to them. This is not like a company that prided itself on customer relationships.

Apr 9, 2018 4:48 PM in response to Budwhite

I switched to iOS into thousand and one due to a stroke and I’ve always used dictation for communication I have used several dictation programs they had problems with learning this latest update to iOS 11 has made it useless. When I get to it shows the right words and then change it to garbage including swearing words. I don’t know how many emails I’ve sent out that of been corrected from the computer after it was sent. They’ve also removed you used to be able to swipe up to highlight the whole page and have it read to you. Apple used to be interested in excess ability. You’re certainly not looking after us know it all

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Is it just me or is voice to text getting worse?

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.