Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

iTunes 12.4 - Various Artist(s) Compilation Woes

Discovered an interesting "quirk" when scrolling through my iTunes music section today. I'm an avid collector of Now That's What I Call Music compilations (do it for completeness sake these days...) and I spotted that 2 albums weren't in the Compilations section in the "Album View" (39 and 58, for those that are interested).


I am fairly meticulous with my albums, so I checked the following:

1. Is the compilation box checked on all songs in the album? Yes

2. Is the album artist the same for all songs in the album? Yes (Various Artists, btw)

3. Is the album stored in the compilations folder on the hard-drive? Yes

4. Is the sort-by information the same for all songs, i.e. the defaults? Yes

5. Are the songs in the same format (AAC) as the rest of the library? Yes

6. Is the album artwork the same? Yes (here is where I started clutching at straws)


I then started trying a few different things:

1. Deleted the songs from iTunes but not the hard-drive location. Result - no change

2. Deleted the songs from iTunes and the hard drive location (reloaded from trash). Result - no change

3. Saved the files to a different location then deleted them from the original location. Result - no change

4. Changed "Various Artists" in the Album Artist box to "Various Artist". Result - moved to the correct location...

5. Changed a single song from "Various Artist" back to "Various Artists". Result - moved to wrong position again...


Does ANYONE have any idea why this is happening and how to fix it permanently? My neuroses can't handle scrolling through the song view and seeing that little wobble between "Various Artists" and "Various Artist" at 2 places along an otherwise immaculate Compilations section 😟


For info:

Running OSX El Capitan - Version 10.11.6

On MacBook Pro Retina 15" Mid-2015

MacBook Pro with Retina display, OS X El Capitan (10.11.6)

Posted on Aug 6, 2016 1:34 PM

Reply
6 replies

Jan 13, 2017 5:50 PM in response to jaj_danbury

jay_danbury: Thank you for posting your solution and what the real source of the problem was!


I've been picking at this scab of a problem for months -- attempting various things to fix it -- to no avail until now. Luckily, I scrolled down past the post you marked as "Solved" to find your 8/22/16 post which revealed that the real fix was to:


make sure the same exact name does not appear both in the "artist" field and the "album artist" field.


One of my tracks was the culprit. What was so frustrating is that, like you too discovered, iTunes had correctly stored this one misbehaving compilation album in the compilations folder under /iTunes Music/Music folder, so iTunes recognized the album as a compilation. Yet it refused to sort the album under the Compilations section of Library/Albums section. Drove me crazy.


"Immaculate" database perfection inside my iTunes Library must satisfy my OCD tendencies!

Aug 7, 2016 11:44 AM in response to jaj_danbury

Hi jaj_danbury,


I understand that two of your albums are not showing as compilations like they should be. I know how important it is to keep things organized, so I'd be happy to share some information with you that may help.


Take a look at this article that may shed some light on your issue:

If you see unexpected groups of songs when you browse an album - Apple Support


Take care!

Aug 22, 2016 1:42 PM in response to jaj_danbury

If you see unexpected groups of songs when you browse an album - https://support.apple.com/HT204538 - "Songs from the same album might not be grouped together as you expect when you view them in the Albums view in iTunes."


The next sections provide additional solutions:


Steve MacGuire a.k.a. turingtest2 - iTunes & iPod Hints & Tips - Grouping Tracks Into Albums - http://www.samsoft.org.uk/iTunes/grouping.asp (older post on Apple Discussions http://discussions.apple.com/thread/2099465?answerId=9910895022#9910895022)


Quick answer: Select all the tracks on the album, File > get info (or right-click > get info > details), and either give them all a single "album artist", or check the "compilation" flag (as in https://discussions.apple.com/thread/3756735?answerId=17670085022#17670085022).


If these are from multiple-CD sets you may also need to enter the appropriate information in the disc number fields. If they are not a multiple CD set you still need to make sure the disc number fields are set correctly or all empty.


Another explanation by hhgttg27 August 2015 - https://discussions.apple.com/thread/6864334?answerId=27784417022#27784417022


If they still really do not want to group check this Aug. 2008 post by turingtest2 about temporarily changing labels - https://discussions.apple.com/thread/1670662?answerId=7904806022#7904806022 or http://www.samsoft.org.uk/iTunes/merge.asp - Add a letter at the end of the artist name, close the Get Info window, then open it again and remove the letter. This often works but I have had cases where tracks grouped when a letter was added but ungrouped when it was removed again.


If they are mp3 files try changing the ID3 tag version which may cause iTunes to re-write the tags and clear up inconsistencies. I use iTunes 7.5 (yes, from 2007) so I can't tell you where this is in later versions.


I had one case of really stubborn grouping. The tracks would re-group in ways that didn't make sense when I changed metadata. Without going into detail, I deleted the tracks completely from iTunes, then re-added the files and they all grouped correctly.

Aug 22, 2016 1:48 PM in response to Limnos

Limnos wrote:


...



If they still really do not want to group check this Aug. 2008 post by turingtest2 about temporarily changing labels - https://discussions.apple.com/thread/1670662?answerId=7904806022#7904806022 or http://www.samsoft.org.uk/iTunes/merge.asp - Add a letter at the end of the artist name, close the Get Info window, then open it again and remove the letter. This often works but I have had cases where tracks grouped when a letter was added but ungrouped when it was removed again.


If they are mp3 files try changing the ID3 tag version which may cause iTunes to re-write the tags and clear up inconsistencies. I use iTunes 7.5 (yes, from 2007) so I can't tell you where this is in later versions.


I had one case of really stubborn grouping. The tracks would re-group in ways that didn't make sense when I changed metadata. Without going into detail, I deleted the tracks completely from iTunes, then re-added the files and they all grouped correctly.

I tried the first and last parts in isolation, to no avail. The final solution that worked was:

1. Create AAC versions (already AAC, but hadn't tried it yet!)

2. Deleted the originals; into the trash then delete

3. Added a space after the album artist (on the new copies I kept) which moved them to the correct location

4. Deleted the additional space and miraculously they stayed put!


Thank you for the idea of converting the files; although rereading your message, I don't think you explicitly mentioned it!

Aug 22, 2016 2:07 PM in response to Limnos

Moments after writing this I realised what the real source of the problem was and it nothing to do with anything in either your answer or the one that I posed as solving the issue. In reality:


1. Both albums (Now 39 and Now 58) had the album artist as "Various Artists"

2. Both albums also had songs that were sung by a collection of various singers, so the album listed the artist as "Various Artists"

3. iTunes wouldn't recognise it as a compilation but rather an album sung by the artist "Various Artists"

4. I added a space after the tracks which listed the artist as "Various Artists"; the albums immediately jumped to the correct location in compilations


As an aside, iTunes wouldn't put single tracks from a compilation (I have Let It Go from the Frozen soundtrack), but when I paired it with another single from another soundtrack (I See Fire from the Hobbit soundtrack) they immediately jumped to the correct location in compilations.

iTunes 12.4 - Various Artist(s) Compilation Woes

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple ID.