Sync option grayed out in Windows 10 with iTunes 12.5.3
I purchased and sync'd my iPhone 6s in March of this year and had been syncing to iTunes just fine until I went to update it to iOS 10. Now, I will admit I don't do regular syncs/backups but now I get two options no matter what:
1) Set up as new iPhone
2) Restore from backup - my backups from March aren't even listed. It shows a backup from February which was on my previous iPhone 5 device.
What are my options now? I want to use iTunes and be able to sync. I know I can use iCloud but that isn't my preference at this time. I did back up to iCloud and update the iOS to 10.
I want to know why my sync option is grayed out. Please help. iTunes should not be treating my device like it is new.
iPhone 6s, iOS 10.1.1