Dual display over usb c on new MacBook 2016

I'm trying to get 1 usb c cable out of our new 2016 MacBook to drive to external displays (not mirrored but extended). Ever dock I look at that has 2x outs says that the new MacBook can only mirror two displays. See except below. Has anyone been able to do this? I would appreciate any help you can give.


Thanks so much!

Rob


http://www.macworld.com/article/3162727/macbook-accessories/caldigit-usb-c-dock- review-a-full-featured-usb-c-dock-with-b…


CalDigit’s dock supports up to the 4096 x 2160 pixel resolution at 60Hz maximum on the MacBook Pro. But as noted above, it can’t drive two external monitors as distinct displays through its two ports.

The company says that stems from a choice Apple made in implementing multi-stream transport (MST). MST differs from single-stream, in that it allows multiple distinct video desktops to pass over a single connection. This manifests itself both as monitors that combine two streams into a single display, and as adapters like this one that can split two desktop signals to appear on two separate displays.

While Apple says its 2015 and later MacBook Pro models can handle an MST display, handling two displays is off the table for now. CalDigit says a specific MST function called “MST hub” is not turned on in macOS, but believes Apple could enable it later. With Windows, the dock can drive two separate external displays on a capable Windows system.

Posted on Feb 17, 2017 11:03 AM

Reply
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Posted on Dec 6, 2017 2:59 PM

I have an early 2016 MacBook. I wanted to have access to more ports. Following @kenmaryj Apr 23, 2017, 1:30 AM post, I tried the Diamond Multimedia Ultra Dock Dual Video USB 3.0/2.0 Universal Docking Station (DS3900V2). I drive a hp EliteDisplay E242 and a hp Pavilion 27xw through this docking station.


It comes with the necessary cables. Just make sure, that sometimes even after downloading the display link drivers, the monitor doesn't light up. If that happens, right after installing, when it prompts to restart, DO NOT Restart.

Open system preferences --> security and privacy --> general tab --> there will be a allow button which will suggest DisplayLink driver is blocked --> click allow.

Then go back to the installation window and click Restart. The monitor should light up after your machine boots up!

23 replies

Jun 9, 2017 4:42 PM in response to Nev369

Nev369 thank you for this solution it is working for me on a Macbook 2015. I get three monitors found the two Dells and the built-in one on the macbook showing in extended mode. But I can also switch to mirroring in "preferences" "display". Running 2 different dell 1080p monitors one to vga using a small dvi-to-vga adapter at the docking station and the other directly to the dvi connector on the docking station.


Only one issue is that the Macbook does not seem to be getting power and is running off the battery. Do you use another adapter for this that will allow power to pass-thru?


Thanks again you rock!

Jun 10, 2017 6:53 AM in response to Retna

Hey Retna, glad to hear this was helpful for you!


I'm currently using the 2 thunderbolt ports on the right side of the laptop for the monitor dongles, leaving the two on the left side free, so I'm just powering up from the left side power port.


I have seen an adapterif you are using one of the macbooks that only has 1 port on each side that allows for you to use USB C passthrough for power, as well as HDMI and a couple other ports. That one's rated well and is fairly priced.

Aug 3, 2017 9:17 AM in response to rcreff

"CalDigit says a specific MST function called “MST hub” is not turned on in macOS, but believes Apple could enable it later. With Windows, the dock can drive two separate external displays on a capable Windows system."

I think the plot is a bit thicker because macOS WILL do MST when you use an Apple Cinema display. And in fact, if you daisy chain multiple non-Apple displays together but hang a thunderbolt device somewhere in the chain it WILL daisy chain as well!

As you say, the hardware works to daisy chain in Windows. Therefore I think macOS is checking to see if the connected display is an Apple Cinema display and/or legit thunderbolt device. If the check fails, the port is downgraded to DP 1.2 and you can only mirror the display. This theory helps explain why this MST issue has been present since they introduced Thunderbolt 2.0 in 2013. The hardware MUST be DP 1.3 for Windows and Apple displays to work. If you google you'll see people complaining about this issue ever since and perpetually hoping the latest OS will fix it. Bugs like this don't stick around for 4-5 years! There is a business decision behind it and I reckon its to sell Apple displays.

Sep 11, 2017 1:50 PM in response to Nev369

Yes, this works using a PC display link "dock." I got the cable and tried on a couple different display link devices at my office. The only downside is, my 2012 MacBook Retina doesn't charge when connected. But I was able to see 3 monitors, my 2 external and my Macbook. Just need to find solution for charging, like a usb-c hub or something.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Dual display over usb c on new MacBook 2016

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.