Hi dialabrain!
"FWiW, the feature has been removed. You can open one PDF first then drag the rest into the Preview sidebar."
Er, no, not quite, at least not on my iMac running High Sierra 10.13 (German version). Preview 10.0 still has the "open all files in one window" option! I use it a lot.
Just to try it out again I selected 3 random PDFs and opened them together. Everything worked as it should, all in one window with 3 tabs showing at the top.
But to be quite honest I've no idea if this option was maybe missing when I did a clean install of HS, but I recently installed the High Sierra supplemental upgrade, so maybe that fixed it? Or could this be some anomaly between the English OS and German OS? Just thought I´d let you know...🙂 Cheers, Ian.