Apple Event: May 7th at 7 am PT
Ok I have the latest fcp and to my knowledge (cannot find anything over than stock quicktime player) and neither will play the audio in the h265. Video is fine, but there is no codecs or drivers available anywhere. So why doesnt my new touchbar mac work with 265 audio
MacBook Pro (Retina, 13-inch,Early 2015), OS X El Capitan (10.11.1)
None of the examples for which you posted the Quicktime Player screenshots appear to have audio.
There is only mention of the video codec (HEVC), and no mention of audio.
Normally one would expect something like this:
Do the clips play with audio on the camera or somewhere else?
What about the clip for which you posted VLC info - and that appears to HAVE audio - does it play? What info does Quicktime Player show about that one?
it plays fine in VLC, for some reason quicktime is not detecting audio but VLC and every other 3rd party app is. I am thinking this has to do with codecs that are not in mac by default. Also when importing to fcp its actually doing the conversion to mov, however even as the original mp4 same thing. Check screenshots same file. Regardless whether what videoI use its the same thing in the windows, check
Baby Jai wrote:
Now when I watch the h265 video after an import it works fine, however there is 0 sound.
I have no idea why there is no sound.
Just run a test here with H.265 4K footage and the audio works fine.
The issue must not be universal.
Can you screen shot the QuickTime Inspector and post it back?
What camera shot the footage?
Al
Not sure if that is relevant or not, but comparing your vlc screenshots with what I see in my mac (on an HEVC file that DOES play with audio in QT Player and FCP X), I noticed that the order of the streams is reversed (audio is stream 0 on mine, and video is stream 1).
yeah samsung tech support told me I need to get the codec from apple, or convert it to h264 which I guess I am going to do. I thought that it would work with fcpx since it works with vlc on mac. Unless of course vlc comes with more codecs than quicktime does
Tom Wolsky wrote:
If you have the drives to support it I would convert to ProRes, which you can do in the Finder.
Not in the Finder, for the same reasons... the OP will end up with a ProRes file with no audio (I tried it).
Converting to H264 in VLC worked.
Converting to HEVC using one of HandBrake's nightly builds also worked.
Hey Jai were you able to get this figured out? Oddly enough it must be something to do with the NX500 specifically, because I'm having the exact same issue. I was all excited to edit a Multicam clip shot with my NX1 and NX500 and final cut's new HEVC capability. The NX1's audio works fine, shows up in QT and in FCPX, but the NX500's audio is mysteriously absent, even though it plays back just fine in Premiere. Very strange. And very annoying.
parkatz23 wrote:
Hey Jai were you able to get this figured out? Oddly enough it must be something to do with the NX500 specifically, because I'm having the exact same issue. I was all excited to edit a Multicam clip shot with my NX1 and NX500 and final cut's new HEVC capability. The NX1's audio works fine, shows up in QT and in FCPX, but the NX500's audio is mysteriously absent, even though it plays back just fine in Premiere. Very strange. And very annoying.
Which is which? You wrote audio twice.
Are you on High Sierra?
Open one such file in QT, press command-I and post a screenshot.
A screen shot of the QT Inspector will tell us a lot.
I ran a search for the camera and found this:
Seems like audio has an on/off switch in the menu.
Maybe check this??
Al
When you open a clip in QuickTime X, use the Window>Show Movie Inspector:
Then the Inspector window appears:
Al
this is in vlc on mac
drag and dropped from card to hd
I can only get the audio playing by using my Bluray media player App.
QuickTime X has picture no audio.
Here is the audio report from the BR App:
I believe it is a proprietary Samsung version.
Al
final cut pro x and h265 not working?
