two mics on a snare drum...

I'm going to try recording two mics on a snare drum as part of the whole kit setup. One on top in the usual spot and one underneath. i hear that i'm suppose to switch the bottom snare mic out of phase with the top mic. how exactly is this done in Logic?

thanks in advance...

G5 dual 2ghz, Mac OS X (10.4.8), 7.2.2 : Firepod : k49

Posted on Jan 19, 2007 1:34 PM

Reply
25 replies

Jan 21, 2007 10:48 AM in response to Christopher Jennings

alright, back to a logic specific question...

How do you use the audio on one track to activate the gate on another track? Is this a side-chain thing? Because my bottom snare mic has better seperation from the hi-hat than the top mic i want to use the bottom mic audio to trigger the gate on the top mic. How is this done in Logic?

Jan 22, 2007 11:19 AM in response to Christopher Jennings

Look up side chaining in the manual.

Basically, you put a gate on the channel you want to 'gate', in this case the snare top mic, and on the 'side chain' panel, select the track number that will be the source to trigger the gate. Adjust threshold settings until you get it working the way you like.

For what it's worth, I almost never gate the snare because you can usually hear the gating, and you almost always lose some of the more subtle stuff. Toms on the other hand... I gate those alot, but again - only when I'm going for the dryer, isolated "70's" sound.

And I've never heard that dynamics and condensers are inherently 'out of phase' with each other. Lots of great engineers tape a small diaphragm condensor and a dynamic together on the top snare, then blend to taste. I've never heard any mention of needing to flip the phase...

As I say though, phase is something you should always play with when it comes to recording/mixing drums. It can be a great creative tool (in the right hands n' ears).

Another small diaphragm mic to consider for overheads are the Oktava MC012's. Pretty decent and fairly cheap. I used to use'em a bunch before I moved up to the Gefell M300's...

Jan 22, 2007 4:28 PM in response to Christopher Jennings

Hi,

You might want to take alook at your polar response for both mics.

In order to minimise the leakage from your HiHat,you might want to try to have the Hihat be directly BEHIND the SM57,where the XLR plug is.Also,you might want to take a look at the following pic:

http://nicksevilla.com/images/YES26-WhiteDrumkit.jpg

Although I used this technique to isolate a tom from the ride cymbal,it can still help you out.
On this particular song the ride was used a lot in the chorus,so I had to do it only for that one song.(Yes,Deeper,Magnification,2001).It worked great!
This foam is placed on the mic itself,and you can use whatever foam,but the denser the better.
Auralex has now caught on to this idea,and now sells similar stuff starting this year.This picture is from the Yes Magnification sessions I recorded back in 2000/2001.

I hope this helps you out,
noeqplease

Jan 22, 2007 4:50 PM in response to noeqplease

Christopher,

noeq's advice on the location of the snare mic is what I would suggest as well. But even before that... get different hi-hats! Don't waver here... this will make a significant difference in how well the drums record.

If the hi-hat is too loud in the room, it will be too loud on tape. Fix it at the source FIRST, then proceed with the micing techniques.

And I agree with tinkertoy about gating the top mic. You will more than likely lose most of the subtle ghost notes and "snare-isms" that make the snare part of the over all groove. I personally would advice against it.

Now gating the room mics off the snare and or toms might be more applicable, depending on the type of music of course. That's one way to control hi-hat volume on the room mics.


And I've never heard that dynamics and condensers are inherently 'out of phase' with each other. Lots of great engineers tape a small diaphragm condensor and a dynamic together on the top snare, then blend to taste. I've never heard any mention of needing to flip the phase...



tinkertoy, I don't recall anyone saying there were phase differences between condenser and dynamic mics (unless I missed a thread). We've been referring to the snare drums bottom mic phase being flipped from the top mic.

Jan 22, 2007 5:20 PM in response to Jim Frazier

yeah the whole hi-hat thing is definetly an issue. i've moved the mike around the snare quite a bit, moved the hat back, etc. the best isolation i've achived is micing the snare bottom only but it's obviously not a complete snare sound.

The type of music i'm recording is primarily electro/rock. this is an example of my last, mostly unmixed drum take (don't laugh): http://www.thealsorans.com/dropbox/The-Wildest.mp3

any recomendations for a good hat that lends itself to this type of music?

thanks again guys, the advice has been very helpful.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

two mics on a snare drum...

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.