Apple's Shared Albums Limits

I'm was in the process of moving my rather large collection of photos and albums from Google Photos to Apple Photos, primarily out of privacy concerns with Google. These photos and albums date back to 2003 with almost 250 albums. Creating and sharing photo albums is important to my family & friends and myself as I'm the family photographer. I quickly ran into Apple's surprising limitation on uploading photos and shared album. I was stunned! I would never had thought Apple would place caps on their customers and in such a limiting way.


  • I paid for the 200 GB family storage which I cannot use due to these caps.
  • It seems unreasonable that as time goes on, 200 albums would be enough for many.
  • Per Apple Support page, these limits are "to prevent unintended or excessive use"; what does that mean? Again, I paid for the storage. Shouldn't I be able to use it? I can see this being policy if the service was free but it's not.
  • These limits seem like a good way to prevent new Apple users from taking full advantage of the Apple ecosystem. Placing arbitrary limits on your paying customers makes no sense. None.
  • This policy is a contradiction the way Apple pushes their camera and photo abilities in their advertising.


I'm just frustrated because of the time I've spent on this already and it seems like this transition wont be possible due to these limits. Is there anything I can do to continue the move to Apple Photos?

Posted on Feb 24, 2018 8:43 AM

Reply
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Posted on Feb 24, 2018 11:00 AM

no - albums on iCloud Photo library are not Shared alums - again two totally different things - Photos albums on iCloud Photo Library and share albums have nothing at all to do with each other (except one word in the name - in face shared albums are not even albums, they are really a shared photo stream renamed for some reason) -- you can not have more than 200 shared albums, you can have any number of iCloud Photo Library albums - you keep confusing several totally different things - each is separate and has it own rules and limits or lack of rules and limits


There are three iCloud photo services


iCloud Photo Library - it uses iCloud storage and has no usage Limits and you pay for what you need and use it with no restrictions - it syncs all changes (additions, deletions or edits) made in any connected library to all other connected libraries.

MyPhotoStreeam - a free service that has limits and restrictions and streams photos between connected devices.

iCloud Photo Sharing - another free service that has limits and restriction and streams photos between subscribers

and there also is feature names iCloud Family Sharing which is another totally different and separate service which allows a family group to share an iCloud Storage plan and certain purchases and other features


The restriction you link to apply to the middle two and have nothing at all to do with your paid iCloud storage or iCloud Photo Library or iCloud Family sharing

And none of these services have anything to do with iCloud Family sharing -


As originally answered

Shared albums have nothing to do with iCloud storage or family shared storage - they are a free service and have limits and their usage does not count against iCloud storage - the limits on shared albums have no effect on family sharing or your personal, paid iCloud usage - two totally separate and unrelated topics with no cross over and totally different answers

LN

Similar questions

9 replies
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Feb 24, 2018 11:00 AM in response to BWJSS

no - albums on iCloud Photo library are not Shared alums - again two totally different things - Photos albums on iCloud Photo Library and share albums have nothing at all to do with each other (except one word in the name - in face shared albums are not even albums, they are really a shared photo stream renamed for some reason) -- you can not have more than 200 shared albums, you can have any number of iCloud Photo Library albums - you keep confusing several totally different things - each is separate and has it own rules and limits or lack of rules and limits


There are three iCloud photo services


iCloud Photo Library - it uses iCloud storage and has no usage Limits and you pay for what you need and use it with no restrictions - it syncs all changes (additions, deletions or edits) made in any connected library to all other connected libraries.

MyPhotoStreeam - a free service that has limits and restrictions and streams photos between connected devices.

iCloud Photo Sharing - another free service that has limits and restriction and streams photos between subscribers

and there also is feature names iCloud Family Sharing which is another totally different and separate service which allows a family group to share an iCloud Storage plan and certain purchases and other features


The restriction you link to apply to the middle two and have nothing at all to do with your paid iCloud storage or iCloud Photo Library or iCloud Family sharing

And none of these services have anything to do with iCloud Family sharing -


As originally answered

Shared albums have nothing to do with iCloud storage or family shared storage - they are a free service and have limits and their usage does not count against iCloud storage - the limits on shared albums have no effect on family sharing or your personal, paid iCloud usage - two totally separate and unrelated topics with no cross over and totally different answers

LN

Feb 24, 2018 11:00 AM in response to BWJSS

You are confused


Shared albums have nothing to do with iCloud storage or family shared storage - they are a free service and have limits and their usage does not count against iCloud storage - the limits on shared albums have no effect on family sharing or your personal, paid iCloud usage - two totally separate and unrelated topics with no cross over and totally different answers


LN

Feb 24, 2018 1:02 PM in response to BWJSS

if I'm paying then there should be no restrictions, caps or limits to any of the services.

and there are no limits on anything you are paying for - as stated several times the only limits are on the free services not for the paid service

As to sharing with friends iCloud Photo Sharing is the only service Apple offers and it is free and has limits - 200 albums for one - and it have nothing to do with any paid Apple services

would you just stay with Google (and the privacy issues)

I would never stay with Google for anything because I would never use them because of their extreme invasion of my privacy - I use Duck Duck Go for browsing because of that and Apple Maps etc - you use what ever you want, i choose not to use Google myself

LN

Feb 24, 2018 9:42 AM in response to LarryHN

Hi LN.


Thanks for the reply. I'm basing my question because my uploads were paused as I was moving over to Apple and then I read the following from Apple's support page under iCloud Photo Sharing Limits (https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202299):


"Maximum shared albums an owner can share: 200"


So if they're separate, you're saying I can have over 200 shared albums? If these limits don't apply to paid iCloud storage, why are my uploads paused (per the support doc)?


Thanks.

Feb 24, 2018 11:00 AM in response to LarryHN

I understand now. Thank you. I guess how I saw it is, if I'm paying then there should be no restrictions, caps or limits to any of the services.


So, if you had 250 albums shared with friends and family on Google Photos, would you just stay with Google (and the privacy issues) or is there another alternative method I could use with Apple?

Feb 24, 2018 3:08 PM in response to BWJSS

You might want to reconsider using Chrome as your browser after reading these, particularly #5:

  1. Google Chrome Listening In To Your Room Shows The Importance Of Privacy Defense In Depth.
  2. Unseen Burdens in Chrome That Can Lead a Mac to Lag
  3. How to Manage the Secret Software That Google Chrome Installs on Your Mac\
  4. Google Chrome's Sham 'Do Not Track' Feature
  5. Google is known to "phone home" with users data as was found out with this new Google Photos service: Google Photos may be free — but there's still a cost.

Just some food for thought.

User uploaded file

Feb 24, 2018 9:29 PM in response to BWJSS

I understand now. Thank you. I guess how I saw it is, if I'm paying then there should be no restrictions, caps or limits to any of the services.


Apple's primary design for iCloud services is to access "your" content across "your" subscribed devices.


It is not the optimal tool for sharing large amounts of content.


You want to share a great deal of photo content among many users who are not you. This is not iCloud's strength.


iCloud's primary photo sharing mechanism, iCloud Photo Sharing, can't be hosted on your paid space. Therefore you won't get the level of control or limitless sharing you want.


I suggest checking http://Smugmug.com as an alternative to Google Photos.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Apple's Shared Albums Limits

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.