Otterbox or Lifeproof? Which one do you prefer and why?

Currently using an Otterbox Commuter and its a great case, not bulky at all and doesn't make accessing the charging port or other functions unuseable.

Looking at possibly changing to a lifeproof case but I'm not sure so I'm asking for opinions on what others think

IF you have an Otterbox, what kind and what about it do you like? Are there things you don't like about it?

IF you have a Lifeproof, which one and what about it do you like? Are there things you don't like about it?

I'm one of those people who can trip over their own feet so I definitely want my phone protected