So, I am trying to resolve the gradual access rate degradation problem and the sudden loss of IP connectivity problem. I’m using the 2018 MacBook Air with Ubiquiti access points. Particularly, two models of acess points: UAP-AC-HD and UAP-IW-HD.
When I first got the 2018 MacBook Air, I was using two UAP-IW-HDs, and the MacBook Air would suddenly lose its association on a known SSID. The Wi-Fi icon on the menu bar would go gray, and the MacBook Air wouldn’t try to re-associate on that SSID or on another SSID that it also had in its list of known SSIDs. I would have to manually select a known SSID for it to re-associate with the UAP-IW-HD. That was happening in late December 2018 and in early January 2019.
Then, some time in mid January 2019 that problem went away. My 2018 MacBook Air no longer lost its association with the known SSID. Instead, it would lose its IP connectivity to the network while still associated with the UAP-AC-HD on a known SSID.
There was a macOS update and a watchOS update (I believe), but there were also a few Ubiquiti firmware updates between late December 2018 and mid January 2019. During that period, the other issue - the gradual degradation of access rates remained.
I raised these issues with Ubiquiti support and engineering, and they tried to reproduce this in their lab, but could not. Finally, in frustration, I replaced one of the UAP-IW-HDs with a UAP-AC-HD, which is a more powerful and more expensive AP that uses a different chipset (Qualcomm instead of Mediatek). I installed the USP-AC-HD about 12 days ago. Since then, I haven’t experienced the sudden loss of IP connectivity issue, but the gradual degradation of access rates still occurs. I noticed that the acess rates stay high for longer periods of time, but eventually the Tx rate degrades down to 13 Mbps. This affects the throughput, because when the Tx rate is 13 Mbps, the upstream throughput is capped at 10 Mbps, which is bad. When the acess rates are at 866 Mbps or 780 Mbps, the throughput reaches 484 Mbps. I am using the 80 MHz channel width on the 5 GHz band.
I have read the post suggested here about the effect of the AWDL (Apple Wireless Direct Link) on the Wi-Fi connectivity that was made a few years ago. That post mentioned an “attack” on the MacBook Pro by the Apple TV. The post mentioned that even when Airdrop is disabled, AWDL is still being used for other purposes, and the attack by the Apple TV was mentioned as an example of such other applications using AWDL. The post also mentioned that AWDL uses channel 149, which happens to be in the range of the 80 MHz channel width that my SSID is on.
So, I ran my 2018 MacBook Air with the AWDL interface turned off (Using the AirFriedX utility by the author of that article) for a few days. At the same time, I kept wondering what would be causing all these Wi-Fi issues with my 2018 MacBook Air and why was it that Ubiquiti couldn’t reproduce my issues even though they were so apparent and easily reproduceable in my environment.
Additionally, there’s a thread on the Ubiquiti forum about these Wi-Fi issues with 2018 MacBook Pros, where half of the posters confirm that they are having these issues with either 2018 MacBook Pros or 2018 MacBook Airs, while the other half insist that they are not seeing any issues.
It was then that it dawned on me that it could be the Apple Watch that I wear that causes the Wi-Fi issues via the AWDL communication with the 2018 MacBook Pro/Air. In the past few weeks, I’ve had a few occasions when the auto-unlock stopped functioning. Once I even had to restore my Apple Watch from its backup to make that feature work again, as no other method would fix the auto-unlock.
All if thise circumstances triggered a link
in my mind between the Apple Watch and the 2018 MacBook Air Wi-Fi issues. I looked up what protocol the auto-unlock with Apple Watch feature uses, and sure enough, it’s AWDL.
This may explain why some people are seeing these Wi-Fi issues with the 2018 MacBook Pros/Airs while others see no issues whatsoever.
I’m still trying to collect the data if the folks who have the Wi-Fi issues wear Apple watches. So far, only a few responded on the Ubiquiti forum, and with the little data that I have so far, my suspicion appears to prove true. Therefore, it would be nice to get the feedback here as well.
Do you experience the Wi-Fi issues described in my post?
What type of Mac (model and year) do you have?
What router/AP do you use?
Do you wear an Apple Watch?
Is there a person in the vicinity with an Apple Watch?
Thank you in advance.