speed and settings changes on Extreme 5th Gen?

For about 7 years I've had excellent speed/reception with my Extreme 5th Gen.

Today I installed a Spectrum-issued new modem to accommodate up to 200mbps

service. (currently 100mb)

Foolishly after activating the modem and restarting the Extreme...I went into the Extreme

settings by way of Airport Utility and long story short, became unable to revert to the previous

settings. Might as well have been a Factory Reset. Sidenote, I also have varying versions of

OS and, of Airport Utility - each seeming to have different capabilities to adjust the Extreme's

settings. I now find speeds are generally slower, and varying on my ten or so different apple wifi

devices.. Speeds with the old Ubee modem were hitting 100mbps even on a desktop maybe 20-40

feet from the base - through a basement floor and multiple walls around the house...

Now quite slower connectivity - best i'm getting is 80-90 mbps. Just feels laggy.


I originally customized the Extreme settings per an apple tech's notes which i cannot find.

It sure seems we had done something relating to channel assignment vs Automatic.. (like "6"

or "11" and also seems we had it set up to effectively 'force' 5g connectivity as the default.

BTW I run both ethernet connected and wifi-only mac devices from this router. So was hoping

some of you experts here might be willing to take a look at some screenshots and advise on

anything i might wanna try adjusting in the current settings that might improve performance.

I can say that I have no devices operating using 2.4g in the home or office FWIW.


I'm not ruling out that Spectrum hasn't yet flipped the switch on my acct to

boost the speed to 200 but even so, this connection seems quite slower than

before - i wonder if there is a Radio Mode or frequency option that would be better...

or something worth experimenting that i could try and see if it might improve things.


I really appreciate any input. Thanks!


Mike

User uploaded file User uploaded fileUser uploaded fileUser uploaded file

Mac mini (Late 2012), OS X Mountain Lion (10.8.5)

Posted on Oct 6, 2018 12:37 PM

Reply

Similar questions

11 replies

Oct 6, 2018 1:20 PM in response to MIKEinMICH

Would really help if we knew what make and model number of modem that Spectrum provided you, since the DHCP and NAT router mode setting on the AirPort Extreme would not be the correct setting to use if the new "modem" is really a modem/router or gateway type of device. The wrong router mode setting could certainly affect speeds and cause other issues as well.


But, first things first. Disconnect the AirPort Extreme from the modem and connect your Mac or other computer directly to the modem using an Ethernet cable connection. Be sure to turn off the WiFi on the Mac.


Now run a few Internet speed checks to make sure that you are receiving the 200 Mbps service that you are paying for.


In other words, it does not make sense to try to troubleshoot a speed issue with the AirPort Extreme if your modem is not delivering 200 Mbps speeds. Once we confirm that the modem is working correctly......and.....we know what type of modem that you have......we'll be in much better shape as far as being able to recommend the correct settings for the AirPort Extreme based on your modem type.

Oct 6, 2018 1:45 PM in response to MIKEinMICH

Speeds with the old Ubee modem were hitting 100mbps even on a desktop maybe 20-40

feet from the base - through a basement floor and multiple walls around the house...

Now quite slower connectivity - best i'm getting is 80-90 mbps. Just feels laggy.

First task is to check that everything with your new modem is actually working properly.


Remove the Airport completely.. plug a computer directly to the modem by ethernet and check your internet speed and latency.


No amount of fiddling will fix a slow modem or actual ISP problems.


Second task.. since you have almost factory reset.. now is the time to ACTUALLY factory reset.

Anytime you change modems.. YOU MUST reset.. so don't kick yourself.. this was necessary part of changing over routers..


I strongly recommend NOT USING APPLE RECOMMENDED NAMES.

Keep them short no spaces and pure alphanumerics. Passwords same rules but can be longer.


You will not get high speeds of 100Mbps (actual throughput that is) without using 5ghz. And penetration of 5ghz is poor.. plus varies greatly over the channels.. low channels are not amplified.. high channels which are actually poorer are amplified to get better penetration.. so you need to use higher channels.


2.4ghz channels are pretty much just for interference.. usually 8 or 9 is a good compromise.. or just leave it on automatic.


You must set 5ghz name different to the 2.4 so you can identify which is which.. clients must connect to 5ghz.. and therefore that name must be top of the list.. and delete all the others in clients that can use 5ghz.


Find out what channel is in operation right now on a computer that should be fast but is slow.

On the computer hold down option key and click the wifi (airport) icon in the top menu.


User uploaded file


This will show you signal strength via RSSI reading.. -52dBm in this case.. pretty OK.

Wireless channel is 112 DFS more below.. but that is good channel.


Tx rate is the link speed with the router.. in this case 867Mbps.. this is AC router.. in the case of a gen5 Extreme the max rate is 450Mbps.. you certainly want a min of 300Mbps to get 100Mbps throughput because wireless is half duplex.. meaning it cannot Tx and Rx at the same time.. so speed is never greater than about half. Remember it is also shared.. so another computer doing upgrades is going to slow the entire network.. you should always test wireless one computer at a time.. everything else OFF.


Best wireless channels on 5ghz are the DFS ones.. these are automatic and cannot be selected.. they cannot be used if it causes interference.. so you cannot force the router to select them.. as that is the case if you want the best.. fix it to one of the higher channels.. above 149.


This is a gen5 extreme same as yours.

User uploaded file


Note the latest firmware could also slow things down.. I use it on 7.6.8 instead of the 7.6.9 .. there is slight security reduction if used with extend wireless of another airport which I would never recommend.


User uploaded file


There is almost nothing else you can do on airport routers.. so you are not missing anything.. it just is very limited in its controls.


Edit .. bob got in first.. I think we read from the same manual. Drink the same kool-aid is the expression I think you guys use??

Oct 6, 2018 2:27 PM in response to MIKEinMICH

I guess I'll do the Factory Reset if i must

Whenever you change the modem or even the service that the ISP provides.....like changing speed plans....you should reset the AirPort back to factory default settings and then set it up again. Reason....the AirPort is still retaining some hidden settings that it used to connect to your "old" modem.....and you won't get the maximum performance out of your "new" modem until you optimize the AirPort with the new modem.


So, that would be the first order of business.


Apple's default settings will provide the best performance for the vast majority of users, so I would check speeds using the defaults first and then consider changing a few settings if speeds or things are not to your liking.


Since you mentioned that your devices will only use the 5 GHz signal from the AirPort, then it would probably make sense to enable the option to assign a different network name to the 5 GHz signal.....and then "aim" your WiFi devices at that signal so they will connect to the 5 GHz signal.


Unfortunately, there are always comprises with any setting on a WiFi router, so setting things up so that devices will connect to 5 GHz will help when devices are close to the router. But.....as you know....2.4 GHz signals are much stronger than 5 GHz signals, so if a WiFi device is a few rooms away from the AirPort Extreme, you will have a stronger signal available at 2.4 GHz and it may well be faster as well.....since 5 GHz signals are absorbed very quickly by any obstructions like walls, furniture, ceilings, etc in the signal path between the WiFi router and a WiFi device.


The bottom line....everything in WiFi involves a compromise. You can have one thing....but you have to give up another thing. There are really no "best" settings that work best in all situations.


If you are getting close to the 200 Mbps speeds when you set up the AirPort Extreme again....I would be tempted to leave things as is......or maybe look at changing a setting or two.


Post back when you have confirmed that the new modem is delivering the speeds that you expect, then we'll concentrate on getting the AirPort Extreme set up in a basic fashion. If things are not your liking, then it would make sense to look at trying a few changes.

Oct 7, 2018 2:45 PM in response to MIKEinMICH

If you get things working at 200 Mbps with your Mac connected directly to the modem, then you can go ahead and set up the AirPort Extreme from its factory default settings.


To start, set things up as Apple designed. That means "Automatic" for Radio Mode and "Automatic" for Channels. Do not assign a separate name to the 5 GHz network yet......that will come later.


For now, we need to get some reference settings on the AirPort to know where to go next. It is very possible that Apple's default setup for the AirPort Extreme might just be better than the results after you try a few "tweaks". Be ready for some surprises.


Regarding 5 GHz......these signals will only work well when you have a "line of sight" relationship between your Mac and the AirPort Extreme. Even adding just one wall between the AirPort and your Mac may drop the 5 GHz speeds in half or more. And, you may find that using 2.4 GHz produces a stronger and faster signal than using 5 GHz.


In other words, it is not really the distance between the router and Mac that really matters. It is the obstructions. I can get 200 Mbps on a 200 Mbps connection easily when my Mac is 75+ feet away from the AirPort if I have line of sight between the router and the Mac. All bets are off though, if there is anything between the AirPort and the Mac.


We'll know more after we have you run some basic tests. No reason to run tests though.....until you have full speeds from your modem.

Oct 7, 2018 1:50 PM in response to MIKEinMICH

Radio Mode. I gather it's best to leave it in Automatic mode.

Yes, leave it on Auto.


I note right now both on a 5g and 2.4g network, my Tx rates are rather poor... from say, 30 feet.

30ft through a floor and a couple of walls will seriously reduce 5ghz speed.


Remember the absolute top speed on 2.4ghz is 217Mbps with later clients.. otherwise it is going to be 130-150Mbps max. So 2.4ghz is never going to be super fast.


I have setup a TC close to the computer.. I am getting full speed 5ghz on it. ie 450Mbps


User uploaded file


What is surprising is how poor the connection is at the other end.

The airport utility will give you a speed at the Mac for each wireless connection.. just roll your mouse pointer over the Client name or IP or MAC address.. whichever is showing up.. a popup will appear as you see below. The signal is excellent.. I am however getting a false reading for link speed.. so you might need to double check this value.. see how you go.

User uploaded file


I have another airport.. same as yours.. a Gen5 Extreme in another room but through two brick walls.. and it does not even show up in a scan.

Wireless on this one has name aegenx

User uploaded file


Nothing shows in scan.


User uploaded file


I also want to point out that the airport does not always pick the right wireless channel.


I have both channels on TC4c set to automatic. It picked 1 for 2.4ghz identical to another AP .. although admittedly with very low signal.. rather than pick 6 between existing.


For signal strength you are always better using the high channels which are now amplified for 5ghz.. but actually test the signal and see how it goes. I did the test and got considerably poorer signal.

Oct 7, 2018 1:57 PM in response to MIKEinMICH

I've been with Time Warner / Spectrum for a number of years and have changed plans and speeds a number of times in the past, including a change about a week ago.


The changes were always completed in a manner of minutes. True, you might need to restart the modem and router for the changes to take effect.


Someone forgot to flip a switch at Spectrum if you are still seeing less than 200 Mbps speeds when you connect your Mac directly to the modem.


Suggest that you get with Spectrum and talk to someone who can do more than just talk.


Post back when you are seeing 200 Mbps speeds when you connect directly to the modem and we'll start to tackle the other questions.

Oct 6, 2018 1:49 PM in response to Bob Timmons

Hi Bob, thanks for your help. I can tell you first off, the modem is a:

Docsis 3.1 'Advanced Voice Modem' - Model E31U2V1.

Just ran the direct-to-modem speedtest via ethernet. Speed has not been

upgraded yet... still around just about 80mbps... That said, I would still like

to know if there are tweaks to the Extreme settings based on modem model

or other aspects - that will optimize it and insure compatibility when Spectrum

gets around to flipping the switch. Thanks!

Oct 6, 2018 2:07 PM in response to LaPastenague

Ok, that is super helpful as well. Thanks! This is a bit of a learning curve for me as it's been 7 years or so since i've even touched this setup... I guess I'll do the Factory Reset if i must.. just hopeful that required information will more or less 'populate' the various fields properly - and if i can downgrade to your firmware version i will. Your detailed answer generates a few questions! It seems somehow previously I had only one network and i seem to recall it always appeared to be operating on a 5ghz channel...is that possible? Like, I had no secondary 2.4g network even in existence...


Also there is rarely any other device online at the same time on my network,when I'm working on my office/studio computers. In doing a quick check of the wifi diagnostics feature, i see on both 5ghz and 2.4ghz channels lower than -50 RSSI...

and this computer is five feet from the Extreme.


You mention the ability to 'fix' a 5g channel to higher than 149... vs Automatic?


I am late for something so have to leave this project for later but appreciate you and Bob breaking it all down for me and will be back in touch. Thanks again!

Oct 7, 2018 3:25 PM in response to Bob Timmons

Many thanks, I appreciate you guys being willing to help me get this reset done

properly - Yeah Spectrum tends to make promises before they've got everything

in place. Found a knowledgeable support guy today who gave me the inside

story that this was supposed to be up last week but the new target for 200mbps

provisioning in my sector is a few days off. Once it's up, I'll be back in touch when

I'm ready to Factory Reset. Meantime, as far as my business usage (in-house)

my studio and office stuff is all ethernet-connected anyway and i don't think I've

noticed any different behavior on those connections with the new Spectrum UBEE

modem and not having messed with anything on the Airport except wifi


Thanks again!

Oct 7, 2018 12:44 PM in response to Bob Timmons

Hi Bob, thanks. I can verify Spectrum hasn't switched me to 200mbps yet but the modem is activated and provisioned for that speed once they complete the upgrade. Meantime I will do the Factory reset on Extreme , but some general questions about Radio Mode. I gather it's best to leave it in Automatic mode. I note right now both on a 5g and 2.4g network, my Tx rates are rather poor... from say, 30 feet.

Both can see as low as 150-200 mbps. I live in a semi-rural area - no competing wifi networks in any direction. I take it there's no special advantage to assigning a specific Channel to either 5g or 2.4g... so in other words, best to just leave everything set as "Automatic" ? Also, I seem to have a problem deleting old named networks which still appear in the WiFi menu on several computers even after attempting to remove them from the Network pane where that is an option. Bit confused about that.


So after Factory reset, when I set about establishing a named 5G network (first- with the checkbox) and then the other, 2.4G network, as I understand it each respective wifi device must be assigned to one or the other... there is no such thing as a single network that allows devices to default to either 5G or 2.4.G network, whichever is best - on their own, right? I'm a bit fatigued trying to work on all this amongst other stuff today so pardon any redundancy or oversights if some questions have already been answered on this. In any event, much appreciated! Mike

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

speed and settings changes on Extreme 5th Gen?

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.