Q: 2018 MBP overheating using external monitor

I have been using this newly upgraded MBP 2018 (i7 2.6GHz, 32GB) for few months now. It is always over-heated while an external monitor plugged.

I have tried the original Apple HDMI adaptor, the 3rd party adaptors, a std. Dell WD15 USB-C docking station. Also tried various monitors, 4K monitor, a simple 1080p old monitor. after few months trying, it seems not the problem of the adapter or monitor, but really the problem of over-heating while the dGPU is using.It works perfectly connected to Dell WD15 docking, for power charging and USB etc. (as long as no monitor connected). The dGPU only kicks in when needed. the idle CPU temp is normal, and system remains completely silent (with CPU fans around 1000~2000rpm)

However, things get completely worse when connecting an external display. The dGPU kicks in, as "always-on" mode, heats the idle CPU temp up from 45° C to 65° C (I repeat: idle). It doesn't matter if it is over HDMI / USB-C, if it is a mirrored / extended desktop or if it is 1080p / 4K that is being driven. If I leave it on (as idle) for a while, or combining this with some light development work, the CPU easily reaches 75° to 90° C and the keyboard starts to radiate uncomfortable warmth to your fingers. The palm rest also gets warm up to the point where my palms start to sweat. The fans try to cool down the system and they speed up quickly up to the point where they become audible and start to really bother me.

Yes, I can and did get an external cooling pad under the MBP (for this 3000 USD laptop), but still no much improvement. actually it finally crash due to the heats today, while copying 1TB files between external HD.

What is really frustrating most is it is even worse than my 4.5 years old 2013 MBP 15, which has the similar design, like dGPU always kicks in while external monitor connected. However, I have never had this over-heating problem in the past 4.5 years.

I did see lots of people having the similar issues with 2018 MBP model, but after days and days research, it seems there is no any real solution for it, and the most feedback I got from my research is "return it back to Apple".


So, Apple, can you please help me? really don't want to go back to PC laptop after 5 years usage of MacBook.

MacBook Pro (15-inch, 2018), macOS Mojave (10.14.1)

Posted on Nov 4, 2018 10:04 AM

Reply
Question marked as ⚠️ Top-ranking reply

Posted on Nov 28, 2018 9:02 AM

I have a 2015 Macbook Pro and experience the same issue with Mojave and external monitor being plugged in via HDMI... It's a big pain. I've tried the SMC reset, removing malware, extensions I don't use and I reinstalled Mojava as well. Sometimes the keyboard gets so hot I can't even use it.

Similar questions

3 replies
Sort By: 
Question marked as ⚠️ Top-ranking reply

Nov 28, 2018 9:02 AM in response to LingoWang

I have a 2015 Macbook Pro and experience the same issue with Mojave and external monitor being plugged in via HDMI... It's a big pain. I've tried the SMC reset, removing malware, extensions I don't use and I reinstalled Mojava as well. Sometimes the keyboard gets so hot I can't even use it.

Reply

Nov 4, 2018 12:19 PM in response to LingoWang

Apple is not here. This is a User-to-User support community.


Welcome!


HDMI is a consumer-class interface invented for HD TV sets at 1920 by 1080p. Although it can sometimes be pushed to "4K" resolutions, that often requires some fiddling. As a "legacy" display interface, it carries the excess baggage of the Heartbeat refresh (new data every 60th second) required by CRT displays. This itself generate a lot of heat -- that data rate is tremendous and unrelenting.


DisplayPort family is a professional-class interface that uses lower voltages, and does NOT carry the Heartbeat refresh. The displays that use it have an internal screen buffer, so they show no flickering regardless. When the screen stops changing, the display cable goes quiet, which can result in less heat generation as well.


In most Macs the External display interface(s) are directly wired to the Discrete graphics chip, if there is one. You don't get to use the Integrated graphics for External displays, because the Hardware is connected there.

Reply

Nov 6, 2018 8:51 PM in response to Grant Bennet-Alder

Thanks, for the reply.


I guess, my immediate issue right now is just the over-heating on the MacBook Pro itself. I understand the D-Graphic Chip concept, and how it works, when an external monitor connected. Actually everything is just working fine as it should be. The only thing is that it is just a lot hotter than what I expected, and what it should befor in my opinion.


Not sure if this is just me, or for everyone, if it is just me, should I bring it to Apple shop, and ask them to check it out?


Lingo

Reply

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Q: 2018 MBP overheating using external monitor

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.