Comcast digital voice

Does anybody know how to bypass the data transfer ports Comcast digital voice uses? I have a problem file sharing with each of my buddies that have Comcast as an ISP.

It is interesting that when I first made them contacts, I was able to file transfer to them and vice versa. Now the only thing that can be accomplished is a one way transfer from them to me. My ability to file transfer in their direction has been halted. I'm guessing it's because those ports are utilised now for some specialized Comcast purpose.

I'm hoping the iChat experts here can help me figure this one out.

Thanks in advance,

Martin J. Estrada

2.0 ghz iMac Core 2 Duo, Mac OS X (10.4.8), Graphite 600 mhz iMac

Posted on Mar 13, 2007 2:04 PM

Reply
6 replies

Mar 14, 2007 2:32 PM in response to Martin J. Estrada

Hi Martin,

File sending is done on the port 5190 on the UDP protocol.

iChat also uses this port but the TCP protocol to Login by default.

Some modems and routers do not like it if this port is opened by Port Forwarding fo both protocols.

Try
iChat > preference > Accounts
Your AIM/@mac Screen Name > Server Settings tab
Change the port to 443 (you have to log outy of AIm to do this)]Log back in again

User uploaded file

9:31 PM Wednesday; March 14, 2007

Mar 14, 2007 3:10 PM in response to Martin J. Estrada

Hi Martin,

This is the bona fide fix for any Zyxel modem.
Same for any Modem or router that needs to specify Protocols when Port Forwarding.

It is a recommended thing to try if having problems with File sending in any set up.

If you type 443 in the search field and press enter and then make sure the search is for iChat you will find lots of posts on the subject. (Normally Defcom, one of the regular posters saying just the change).

User uploaded file

10:10 PM Wednesday; March 14, 2007

Mar 14, 2007 6:08 PM in response to Ralph-Johns-UK

Ralph, I've been having issues getting the video to work with iChat. Tried the port changes, Quicktime streaming changes, etc. but still won't work. Then I got a .mac account because one of the Apple tech guys suggested that but before I could try it out iChat stopped working altogether but I'm gathering from several other posts that I'm not alone with that. Any other suggestions to the error -8? I've also got Comcast internet/cable but no phone service.

Mar 15, 2007 1:17 PM in response to gena17

Hi Gena17,

OK.

Two things.

It seems there was some sort of Outage on the AIM servers yesterday. I could not get iChat to stay on-line in several version of the OS.

As to Error 8 it can cover several things.
1) Once in a while it does relate to the Quicktime not being done.
2) most often it is about ports not being open in
a) the Mac Firewall if it is ON or
b) the modem or routing device.

3) It can be they way you have set up your LAN
If you use a modem and a router - and the modem and the router are both doing DHCP then the computer can be getting an IP from each device and iChat will not know "Where" it is

4) The way the ports are opened in two devices can also play a part.
Most devices will at least do Port Forwarding
If both device do this or Port Triggering or DMZ (Any method that relies on NAT) and also combos of these will cause problems for iChat.
(iChat is not the only AIM based IM app that has problems with NAT transversal)

5) Some people use VoIP equipment to use there phone over the internet (Vonage or similar adapters)
These are sensitive to the SIP Data and presume all SIP is for the phone and "Strip" it out of the the data flow.
Placing the adapter on a port on a router like it was another computer sorts this.

6) Some Modems are SIP aware.
Depending on make and model you can do something about some of these.

7) Some ISPs run VoIP services and block port 5060(-5063) expecting people to pay for the service (Stops people going to Vonage or similar).
Or it is about losing out to "free" long range calls and trying to make money form that.

If your ISP does do 7) then you do not need to use a phone (VoIP specific or landline with and adapter) to be blocked for iChat.

With 7) it does seem that if you point out that your ISP never said there were changing their service and have blocked port 5060 without telling that they will unblock it for you.
You do of course need to be sure of the small print in their original paperwork or anything they have sent to you since.

Summary.
Has the Quicktime setting been done.

Is the Mac firewall On and if so have the ports been set ?

Have the ports been set or allowed in the Modem ?

Do you have two devices on your LAN doing DHCP ?
If so stop one of them at least.
(Static routing on your LAN or turning the Modem into Bridge Mode or the Router into and Access Point)

Are both devices doing a NAT based port opening method ?
If so how is you LAN set up ?
Can you use UPnP in at least one of the devices ?

Do you have any VoIP aware equipment or devices ?
Restructure you LAN for Adapters.
Post back with modem or router details for further advice if it is the Modem or router.

Does the ISP offer a VoIP service ?
Ask them.
Check if you can ping a friend or know IP on port 5060-5063 (Use Network Utility in Applications/Utilities)
Then ask the ISP to unblock it.

The error 8 log can help - to some extent - point you to where you need to start

User uploaded file

8:20 PM Thursday; March 15, 2007

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Comcast digital voice

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.