In my case, I chose component over HDMI simply because the switching and cabling was easier. I've got
all the ports on the back of the HD70 filled (composite, component, HDMI, s-video, VGA) - all 25 ft cables running to the back of the video electronics shelf. (thank heavens for monoprice.com! 🙂
My AV reciever does not do HDMI switching, and most of my video sources (including an xbox360 and wii) don't supply HDMI. So when I ran out of ports on the receiver, I bought a cheapo "gamer" 6-way component switch from Fry's (
http://shop2.outpost.com/product/4737609), which has worked well for me, despite somewhat spotty reviews on the net.
Most of the video material I have to show from the ATV is well below HD quality, anyway. So I just ran it into one of the switcher's ports for convenience. I have the HDMI cable plugged directly into my DVD player.
BTW, I did use my DVD player to do a direct comparison of HDMI vs. component using my HD70. I used some rather demanding material (2001). While I could see some subtle differences, and I think the HDMI looked better, I would not be confident that I would consistently pick HDMI as the "better" choice in a blind test.
And yes, that projector is
awesome... 🙂
Dual 2.0 G5, MacBook Mac OS X (10.4.8)