Live TV/DVR on Macbook

I will pretty soon be switching to a Macbook from my HP Media Center Edition PC, probably around the time Leopard comes out (will take until this summer to get enough money saved up). One of my favorite things about using my HP is the Media Center and the ability to watch and record TV.

I am still holding out that this will be the "Top Secret" feature that Steve Jobs did not tell us about for Leopard, but if it isn't, I would like to have an alternative.

The two products that I have been able to narrow it down to are TVMax ( http://www.miglia.com/products/video/tvmax/index.html) and eyeTV ( http://www.elgato.com/index.php?file=shop_onlineshop).

Has anyone had any significant experience with either of these? I can't really tell everything that I want to know from the advertisements. I would like to be able to watch and record TV with an interactive channel guide. It has to work with the Macbook I'm getting, and, if possible, I would like to not have to plug anything in the computer itself. I hate having to plug in the TV Tuner Card and have my cable connected to that to watch TV on my HP. I will accept having to plug in a USB receiver that is wireless, but I would prefer full wireless. My goal is to have my Macbook set up so the only thing that I have to plug in is my power.

Thanks in advance and sorry for the long post.

HP dv8000, Windows XP

Posted on Mar 27, 2007 7:16 PM

Reply
13 replies

Mar 27, 2007 8:53 PM in response to ross.32

My goal is to have my Macbook set up so the only thing that I have to plug in is my power.


No matter what software developments come with Mac OS X 10.5, it's not going to add any hardware capabilities to an existing model of Apple computer. Since there is no hardware TV tuner built-in to any existing Mac, you'll have to add that part with a hardware device. While a newer version of Mac OS X might facilitate this, a TV tuner will have to be both hardware and software. It's against the Terms of Use of the Apple Discussions to post about unannounced products, so it will be difficult for anyone here to give you any more than some very vague recommendations now. You might be better off posting your topic closer to the time you're ready to make your purchase. Someone will be able to make a MUCH more informed reply then.

With that said, I've been using El Gato EyeTV devices for almost five years. They understand Apple hardware and the Mac OS X experience. They are always quick to update their software when Mac OS X updates are released or new hardware is released. So, for now, I would have to recommend you pursue the El Gato EyeTV hardware that suits your TV requirements. But until Mac OS X 10.5 and all of its features are released and/or any new Apple or El Gato hardware is introduced, no one here is going to be able to give you much of an informed reply.

-Doug

Mar 27, 2007 8:59 PM in response to Douglas McLaughlin

I understand about not being able to discuss future Apple products. My question was more concerned with comparing the products that are out now. With your system, do you have to plug in anything more than a USB cable? And if that is the case, could I get around that by plugging it into a AirPort express?

Noticed after my post...in this picture it shows the product next to the Macbook and it does not appear to be connected though a wire? http://www.elgato.com/index.php?file=productseyetv250gallery&imagecount=1&goto=

Mar 27, 2007 9:15 PM in response to ross.32

That image is misleading. The device must be attached with a cable to your Mac. I use the EyeTV Hybrid. It's about the size of a lighter (barely thicker than the TV antenna cable or the USB extension cable) but it does need to be connected to show live TV or record TV. However, it does NOT need to be connected for your MacBook to play back recorded shows. My EyeTV Hybrid is plugged into my iMac with a USB extension cable and the device itself is plugged into my antenna.

-Doug

Mar 28, 2007 12:54 PM in response to ross.32

No experience with the Miglia product but am in love with the Elgato EyeTV 250. I too am a former Windows user and was absolutely blown away at the ease of use for the 250. Also, I started feeding my VHS tapes into the thing and was very pleased at the ease of use for iMovie and iDVD for editing and burning to DVD the results.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Live TV/DVR on Macbook

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.