HandBrake is just amazing. I really nearly have tried them all:
Mac-Software:
- FourtyTwo (which by the way does not generate h.264, not for me anyway). I am not able to crop. Can handle VIDEO_TS folder. First generate an avi (?!? why ?!?) then starts coding. Slow.
- Compress from Final Cut: the h.264 video will not load onto the 5G iPod and is very slow. The MPEG-4 video coding is extremely fast, but if you compare it to h.264 you see the difference. Great functionality. Can not handle a VIDEO_TS folder.
- Toast 7: does the h.264 coding pretty fast (you have to choose baseline, by the way), but the result is really bad compare to the others. Can handle VIDEO_TS folder.
- Quicktime Pro 7: sloooooow, but good results. Can not handle VIDEO_TS folder.
- HandBrake: In my opinion the Best coder there is. It is fast, can handle VIDEO_TS folder. Very good results (I cannot tell the difference in quality between 1-pass and 2-pass coding, except the 2-pass coding takes very long.) h.264 coding, crop-function, and its free.
Windows-Software:
- Nero Recoder: Fast, NO h.264.
- PQDVD: Which I bought. afterwards I realized it has a problem with the audio (there are glitches, crackling noises throughout the video). You need a DVD-Player installed. Very fast. NO h.264!