I have read through a lot of the complaints here. My issue is with the iPhone 4. I've used the Plantronics Voyager for years, through the various model improvements. Fortunately, I've bought at Best Buy with the protection plan, so everytime one breaks or has issues, I've been able to replace/upgrade. I've had an iPhone since the original 8gig model. My bluetooth has always worked flawlessly, even from the other end of the house, through walls. That is, until the i4. When I connected my bluetooth to my new iPhone 4, it continuously disconnected and my outgoing signal was garbled and fuzzy according to those I was speaking to, most of which were used to me coming in very clear. I returned the earpiece for a new one, but it did not correct the issue.
Here's the wierd thing: It is not always consistent. Every once in a while, it gets great distance and clarity. A week or so ago, it was working exceptionally well. Then this past week, it went back to being fuzzy or disconnecting if it's more than 2' or out of line of sight. If I set my iPhone 4 on the left side of my desk, (just to the left of my left elbow while typing on my laptop) with my earpiece in my right ear, it will disconnect. While driving in my car, if I don't hold the phone in the air, within 2' of my right ear, my outgoing voice gets fuzzy and digitally garbled to the recipient, even though I can hear them perfectly clear.
I've had an iPhone 8gig, 3gs, and now the 4. It is most definately an issue with the 4. I've paired my earpiece back with my old 3gs (my son has it), and it works just like it used to: long distance with no fuzz. My only thought is that it is possibly linked to the internal antenna issues that apple already knows about. I've got so much invested in the iPhone platform that I'm not about to switch to another, but it is terribly inconvenient not to be able to leave my phone in the holster, on the same side of my body as my earpiece, and be able to clearly communicate with someone. (And yes, I've tried a great number of holsters, covers, lack of covers, etc., with no difference in functionality.)
I really do hope this issue will be corrected with the i5. I will try it out with someone else's before I buy. If the bluetooth issue is not corrected, I will not buy another iPhone until it is.