Need a calendar server for Mojave

I just got a 2018 Mac Mini to replace our aging Mini server. I really didn't want to upgrade our server to Mojave, but there was no choice… meaning our calendar server is now dead, dead, dead.


Apple put up a page with four recommended replacements. After reviewing them, I can only describe my reaction as horror.


Kerio Connect is a Microsoft Exchange replacement that also offers email and IM, for "only" $465 plus $150 per year indefinitely. Way more than I want for way more than I can afford (not to mention I'd rather introduce herpes into our workflow than Exchange).


DavMail offers similar services as a front-end to Exchange, which we do not have.


Radicale looks interesting, but every place on the website where they discuss how to install or use it on MacOS, it says "to be provided." (I am aghast that this package, in this state, earned a recommendation from Apple.) Also, there is a lot of weasel wording on the order of "this was a student project / it implements parts of the standard / we don't do A, B, or C" that FUDs me out.


CalendarServer shows promise, but it's the most opaque of the bunch.  The instructions for "downloading a version of Calendar and Contacts Server to run on a server" actually creates some sort of non-executable development branch for programmers, and the "admin guide" assumes you are a software developer who knows all about unrelated packages and how to obtain them. Again, I am horrified that Apple actually recommended this package as a replacement for its mostly plug-and-play Server. It's like Ford recalling your car and replacing it with a blueprint (not even a kit)!


Does anybody have any suggestions for usable replacements for Calendar Server? (Cloud-based services are not an option, sorry.)



Mac mini 2018 or later

Posted on Dec 21, 2018 10:56 PM

Reply

Similar questions

3 replies

Dec 24, 2018 9:11 AM in response to macswe

Background: I’m not inclined to spend my time creating and maintaining and updating and securing my own server distro on macOS, which makes me less interested in the approach that Apple is offering. I’ve done that before, and it gets time-consuming to keep everything current and secure and integrated, and to sort through the various and inevitable package update notices as all the pieces and parts get updated (asynchronously). Sometimes on short notice too, as security issues are reported or are being exploited.


Here? I don’t (yet?) know of a good add-on CalDAV server for Mojave macOS 10.14.


Accordingly, I’d acquire an older Mac mini and use that until you figure out where you’re headed with your server, or I’d acquire new or would use use a spare x86 box and install OwnCloud or NextCloud or analogous software installed in that, and that probably booting Linux or BSD. Or I’d use the CalDAV calendar server package that various other distributions either install or offer.


There are various vendors that offer packaged systems with related capabilities. Synology Network Attached Storage (NAS) offers various free and extra-cost plug-ins, including Calendar and mail. Yeah, you already have a 2018 Mac mini, so this NAS approach might not be thr path you want to follow.


As should be clear from the abovd, I’m not planning to continue to use Apple for server functions. Not unless a pre-packaged server distro again becomes available, and quite possibly not then.


I have worked some with Kerio, and it does work well. It’s not cheap, and it does lack some of the services I’ve been using with macOS and Server.app, too. But again, it works well.



Dec 26, 2018 3:00 PM in response to MrHoffman

As an experiment, I tried booting the new Mini on High Sierra from an external, thinking I might be able to reclaim the old Server functionality that way. Even after reducing the new boot security protection levels to their minimums, absolutely no joy — it refused to boot.


Looks like I will be adding a Linux VM just to handle my family calendar to the Windows VM that routinely runs on this machine. I guess I'm going to be squandering that new CPU power sooner than I expected.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Need a calendar server for Mojave

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.