Hi JoshD13,
If you are using a motion template, or a generator, the clone solution described from Fox is the way to do it. However, if you are using a titles template, or an effects template, then the reverse feature of a clone is not available.
If that is the case, you can convert the overshoot behavior to key-frames. With the behavior selected, use 'cmd K' on the keyboard, or you can choose it from the 'object; menu. Then you can reverse the key-frames you just made.
Step 1 : Duplicate the overshoot behavior position it to where it needs to be

Step 2: Convert to key-frames

Step 3: Reverse the key-frames

If you need to use this method, you must be sure that you are happy with the overshoot animation first, because covering to key-frames will delete the original behavior and all the adjustment parameters are gone too. But you can easily 'cmd Z' to undo everything to go back.
Ok, so, if you can use the reverse clone method - that is always your plan A, but for title templates and effects templates, you have this method as Plan B.
