Peter Roussak wrote:
I'm not sure what you mean about doing a clean install to an external and test.
Install an OS preferably High Sierra onto an SSD external disk.
Get macOS High Sierra.
Then boot from it and test with just the default install. (That will tell if it's your internal HDD or possibly another piece of hardware at fault) If that works well then install only the third party applications you need. For then on you can work off that external drive. And when you do replace the Mac, you have a fast external hard drive for your new one.
I did try clicking on Clean Up but I'm not sure what I'm suppose to see happen. Should I run the test again and see if the orphaned items are still there?
Sure, you can Etrecheck as many times as you like.
maybe I should install ibackup and follow the official uninstall instructions as Eric suggested (if I ever had it installed I would have used AppDelete to remove it but perhaps something got left behind.)
Can't hurt.
FWIW I'm running on a 2010 iMac myself. It's the 27". Only difference is the 7200 rpm drive vs. the 4500 yours has. It still runs as fast as the day I got it, still on the original 7200 rpm spinner. If the hard drive goes I plan to replace it with an external SSD and run from that. I'm hoping to get another couple of years out of it, vintage or not.