Why do I hear previous take when recording?

I found the answer. I had duplicated another vocal track that had the Melodyne ARA plugin on it and I hadn't thought to power it off or remove it. When it's on, you can hear the previous take. When it's off you can't.

Thanks @Iaamusic for the time you spent trying to help figure it out!

The preferences are to create a take folder whether cycle is on or off. I'm not using cycle mode. But when I turn cycle mode on I can still hear the previous take when doing a new take. (this is true for any combination of cycle/autopunch for that matter, and even when cycle starts before autopunch, which supposedly fixed this issue for someone else.).

Opinion: If I were designing the UI / writing the code for this and variables were set that allowed you to hear previous takes while recording a new take, I would be throwing up some big yellow or red in-your-face warning or button or something saying, "Settings X, Y and Z are set so you will hear previous takes while recording a new take, which you typically don't want to hear. Do you want to disable that?"

I admit I'm just a lowly, simple home recorder and I don't know a lot, so I am open and interested in knowing if my perspective is off on this, and if there are legitimate times when you do want to hear the previous take when recording a new one. I could see it maybe when doing vocal doubles and you like a previous take and know you want to use it as one of the doubles, but this seems it would be secondary functionality at most and definitely not the default for doing takes.

I have enabled some advanced options:

I don't remember ever having this issue before installing Focusrite's Automap Server. That said, I don't have a solid correlation between this issue and Automap. But I did just want to put it out there in case that rung any possible bells.