AhliasTPCC1 wrote:
my Internal HDD S.M.A.R.T. Status is “Failing”. I ran first aid on both the disk and the volume and it said everything was ok. But the S.M.A.R.T. Status is still “Failing”
I'd swap that storage device.
If it's a hard disk drive, I'd also swap for an SSD if I planned to keep this Mac for a few years. SSDs are vastly faster. And if the Mac supports an upgrade—newer models don't—I'd add more memory while the box is open.
Even in the unusual event that the SMART data is mis-detecting failures or that this detected error is benign or otherwise isolated, I'd still assume the storage is failing. Hard disk drives can and do fail. (As can SSDs, but those usually fail hard.)
One hard disk drive failure pattern is degrading performance and corruptions and crashes. Eventually, that pattern usually transitions over into increasingly-visible storage errors when the data written cannot be read back, or the data is corrupted when written, and eventually outright failure.
Repairs and reconstruction doesn't fix these cases, and the I/O activity involved in verification and repair attempts can serve to push the storage further into failure.
Get a backup if not already, and expect to have that storage device replaced. Local rule of thumb is backups first and second, and maybe poking around third or fourth, prior to the swap. Use whatever remaining I/O might be available to preserve data, if there are not current backups.
Terminal and the command line will provide little benefit past what the higher-level tools can already achieve.
SMART tries to be predictive—giving some warning of impending failure, as is this case—but is also not reliably predictive of failures, too. SMART has empirically missed many hard failures.
If you want to poke at the SMART data and see how bad this device is—given your inferred proclivities here, I'd expect that's going to be of interest, DriveDX can be useful. But ensure you have complete and current backups first, should this storage device be following the usual pattern of degrading toward failure.
And FWIW, among those Mac models that can be repaired or upgraded, some are easier to repair or upgrade than others. The iMac 21.5" series isn't particularly "fun" to repair or to upgrade, though it's possible.
Given the 2011 vintage here, this iMac is probably better replaced with a new or new-to-you Mac
If you do decide to buy new, the current low-end 21.5" iMac configuration is good for mail and FaceTime and looking at photos and such, but the entry-level 8 GB memory with a 5400 RPM hard disk drive (slow!) is going to be very slow for many tasks. The mid- and higher-spec iMac configurations include SSD, and are vastly faster.
Backups? Booting Recovery and using Disk Utility is the usual path for creating an external backup of an internal storage device.
If you can't repair or replace right now, using Disk Utility from Recovery to copy your internal storage to external and then booting from the fastest available external storage can provide a work-around for a failing (or failed) internal storage device.