Apple Intelligence is now available on iPhone, iPad, and Mac!

Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

smb vs afp on Catalina for MyBookLive

I have an old MyBookLive which I bought in 2011. It has a 800 Mhz processor and 256 MB RAM. I have been using Chronosync to backup up folders and files from by 2016 MacBook Pro with Touch Bar from days of Lion until Catalina.


I have always used afp to connect to the shares in MBL. The transfer speed has always been only 1-2 mbps even though my home wifi is supposed to be 1 Gpbs fibre. I guess it has to do with both the MBL as well as the file protocol.


I read that afp has been deprecated more than 6 years ago since Mavericks. The last release was AFP 3.4 over seven years ago, and since the introduction of Apple’s new file system APFS, it hasn’t been supported for the sharing of APFS volumes, only for the older HFS+.


We are encouraged to use smb in place of afp. I can connect to MBL using smb. The MBL shares seem to mount faster with smb than with afp. After mounting, I ran smbutil statshares -a and found out that all the shares were connecting using smb 2.002. I heard the best is smb version 3. But when I use Chronosync to run the backups, the speed was pathetic: between 11 kbps and 90 kbps!!! I read that smb 3 have far superior transfer speeds than afp.


Here's my question. Given that my MBL is old, is it advisable to stick with afp, or it doesn't matter if my MBL is old. I should find a way to run smb3 instead of smb2?



MacBook Pro with Touch Bar

Posted on Jun 4, 2020 10:00 PM

Reply
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Posted on Jun 5, 2020 10:27 PM

Thanks Barney. I keep the MBL firmware updated quite regularly. Perhaps it just can’t support smb 3. I can’t even get a transfer speed of 10 mbps. Forget about 200 or 500 mbps. I’ll be happy with 10-20 mbps and not 1-2 mbps.

Similar questions

2 replies

Jun 5, 2020 4:31 AM in response to Christopher Yip

I have always used afp to connect to the shares in MBL. The transfer speed has always been only 1-2 mbps even though my home wifi is supposed to be 1 Gpbs fibre. I guess it has to do with both the MBL as well as the file protocol.

Unless your drive is on one end of the Internet and your Mac on the other, your internet service speed has nothing to do with it. Most WiFi routers max out at around 240 mbps. Even routers that advertise "gigabit" speed share that speed among all connections to it. So, if you had a router with that kind of transfer speed, your two devices could only manage 500mbps each.


File sharing also has its own overhead which slows things down. It can only transfer as fast as it can read/write the information to the drive.


You should use the protocol that works best.


The MBL probably doesn't have SMB 3 as it was releases with Windows Server 2012. If you can update the firmware on it, then you might be able to have it share via SMB 3.

smb vs afp on Catalina for MyBookLive

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.