DogwoodD wrote:
But your statement regarding iCloud as a sharing service and not a backup is puzzling when Apple clearly markets it as a backup.
I think, that is a misunderstanding. I have not seen a single document, where Apple is claiming that iCloud Photos is a backup. Apple says "Keep your photos safely stored in iCloud", but that is something completely different. For example, the Photos User Guide is clearly describing iCloud Photos as a syncing service:
https://support.apple.com/guide/photos/from-icloud-photos-phtf5e48489c/mac
With iCloud Photos, all the photos and videos in your photo library are stored in iCloud, so you can access them from your Mac, PC, iPhone, iPad, or Apple TV, and on iCloud.com.
Any new photos and videos you add to Photos, or take with an iPhone or iPad, appear on all your devices that have iCloud Photos turned on. Your photos and albums are organized the same way on every device, and if you make edits or remove items, you see the changes on all your devices.
If you are using iCloud Photos as the central storage of your photos, you are working with the iCloud Photos and you need a backup, so you can recover photos that you accidentally delete. And worse, if you are using iCloud Photos on an iPhone or another iOS device, your photos will no longer be included in your iCloud backup of the iPhone or iPad. And if you are using iCloud Photos and optimise storage on a Mac, it will also make your Time Machine backups incomplete, because the optimised originals are not included in the Time Machine backup. iCloud Photos is very useful for syncing, but does not suffice as a backup, it is even making backing up the photos harder. Three Good Reasons for Using iCloud Photos Library and when not to use it - Apple Community