Cannot Enable "Use your Apple Watch to unlock apps and your Mac"
Due to some rather uninteresting circumstances, I recently had to reset my Apple Watch and restore it to a backup. Since, I have been attempting to enable my Mac's "Auto Unlock" feature where my Apple Watch will unlock it or allow me to authenticate.
Each and every time I click the empty checkbox (located in System Preferences > Security & Privacy) to enable, I get the loading indicator and a "turning on" message, eventually followed by this:
My Mac supports the feature
Both the Watch and Mac are up to date on the software side
Apple Watch has a passcode
Mac has a passcode
The Watch is on my wrist and unlocked
Both devices have bluetooth and WiFi turned on
I have two-factor authentication enabled on my Apple ID and both devices are signed in to the same account
I have no idea why this isn't working.
Suggestions?
MacBook Pro 15”, macOS 10.15