I had a similar issue which was so disappointing. did factory-reset myself, updated my phone, none of them worked then took my phone to Genius Bar.
They run the displace accuracy test two times. My two tests were failed and the Genius Bar employees test weren't.
The diagnosis was that my fingernails were making contact with the screen and I've been advised to not use my nail!!!
My nails are short and the second test was with my finger with the shortest nail that one person can have.
This is faulty and Apple should accept it instead of bringing these unreasonable excuses.
I got another appointment and will ask them to admit it's faulty because I want to return this phone.