iPhone 12/Pro/Pro Max Leather case patina not developing compared to previous leather cases

Hi,


Anyone out there with the new leather case for iPhone 12 series notice that the feel of the new leather case seems somewhat different compared to previous cases (e.g 11/XS/X)?


The finish feels more synthetic, not sure if it's because of any surface coating.


I'm using a saddle brown case myself for my 12 Pro Max and it's the first time that there is absolutely no signs of patina on the case after a week of use, looks as good as new and this baffles me.


It definitely wasn't like that on my previous saddle brown cases, wondering if anyone is experiencing the same on their leather cases especially saddle brown ones.


noticed similar comments to macrumors forums as well:

https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/apple-leather-cases-patina-proud-photos.2091430/page-140?post=29282055#post-29282055


if it doesn't develop similar patina to previous cases, it would be very disappointing.


or perhaps someone from Apple can comment on this too.


Thanks in advance!

iPhone 12 Pro Max, iOS 14

Posted on Nov 23, 2020 8:22 AM

Reply
Question marked as Top-ranking reply

Posted on Apr 20, 2021 5:05 AM

That’s actually a good suggestion so I actually took it up with the Apple store. They said many complaints have been coming precisely with the same issue as a matter of fact the Store sales person confidentially informed me that he to experienced the same problem and is purchasing a different brand of case. Unfortunately he said they cannot accept a return of the case and it was manufactured differently not defective. Meaning this year they no longer use the high quality Tanned Coach style leather. They used a cheap hard leather and painted it with a cheap paint finish that rubs off after only a short period of time. This process is not a true “tanning process“ it’s just a “spray on tan“ and only gets worse over time it doesn’t get aged with a beautiful patina. Now for those of you that like the rubbed off paint look finish as “vintage“ I gather you would like this style. Personally I’d like to see them bring back the high-quality truly “tanned process” leather case. Here are some photos of the original high-quality case. No that’s a true patina aged Tanned saddle brown look! Please Bring it back



Similar questions

81 replies

Feb 20, 2021 4:50 PM in response to Applewibe

Hello Applewibe. Please don’t misunderstand my post about the saddle brown patina “issue”. I have both the black and saddle brown leather cases for my 12 Pro and I love them both. The cases fit perfectly, the MagSafe is great, the metallic buttons are very responsive and “clicky”, after a few days the cases start to become very grippy and they are as thin as they could be. I highly recommend them.

Apr 26, 2021 1:37 AM in response to Yoniapple67

Why in the world to we pay 90 NZD (or equivalent) for a original Apple case to them receive so cheap **** that I could have ordered on wish or similar?

Why is nobody in the US holding Apple responsible for this? Do you not have any consumer protection laws?


I am really ticked off by this!


Has anyone contacted Apple directly and got an answer regarding this issue?

Aug 21, 2021 12:21 AM in response to agnieszka148

Agnieszka czyli dwóch polaków gadających po angielsku 😁 kupiłem w media expert brak paragonu nic zadzwoniłem na Apple care (masz telefon: 00 800 4411875) powiedziałem że proszę technika do telefonu bo na pierwszej linii są ludzie którzy cię zbywają. Poprowadził moją sprawę obejrzał zdjęcia i załatwił wymianę na ich koszt w cortlandzie. 👍 nie wiem co jest w naszym narodzie że boi się coś reklamować…

Aug 23, 2021 9:26 PM in response to Stanmeh

Apple — I read through all this discussion. It doesn’t appear you’ve issued a formal response to this persistent complaint? Why not?


We are angry.


Some might say this is petty or trivial. Perhaps. But that would be saying art, beauty, craft, design, and the relentless pursuit of perfection are petty. Apple’s very DNA is principled upon DESIGN is it not? Our iPhone is the device/tool we most use in our life. It’s feel and look should not be compromised… is should reflect the quality and beauty APPLE has always stood for…


So to sell us a saddle brown “leather” case that overtime rather than developing a beautiful patina by aging into a darker richer softer saddle brown leather with the added improvement of becoming easier to grip you’ve SOLD us a cheap faux feeling painted on brown that over time “scuffs” revealing BLACK and becomes harder and harder to hold onto. I now drop my phone several times a day as a result of this horrible change you’ve made to the once AMAZING IPHONE CASE.


I feel duped. You sold us something that LOOKED like the previous Apple cases which wasn’t. Why? Who made this decision and to what end? Was it to save money? Was it for environmental reasons?


As an Apple customer since 1978 and iPhone customer since 2008, I implore you to responsibly provide us with an explanation… not an excuse, an explanation…. PLEASE.

Dec 16, 2021 6:03 PM in response to Stanmeh

Can anyone tell me how does one even ask Apple for a replacement? I contacted them, they said that this is a cosmetic damage and is not covered under warranty. My red leather cover developed those gross black lines on all edges with just two months of use.

I would have opened a case with European consumer center but that does seem quite hectic with months of waiting and all.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

iPhone 12/Pro/Pro Max Leather case patina not developing compared to previous leather cases

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.