Photos not going to My Photo Stream on iPhone 12 Pro

I believe I've found the trigger.

I did a 'Reset all Settings', and Photo Stream started working fine. I then went to try toggling settings one by one, and the very first one broke Photo Stream. In Camera Settings, under Formats, set to "Most Compatible" breaks it. Switching it back fixes it.

It is just on the iPhone 12 Pro. Changing the same setting on my wife's SE does not break it.

Please check yours and see if you have "Most Compatible" set, and try toggling it.

Also the same happens to me.

With “Most Compatible” setting enabled, some photos not going to Photo Stream.

But if I set that option on “High Efficiency” everything start to work again and as I expected.

So I really suspect that Camera Format options are buggy with Photo Stream when is enabled “Most Compatible”.

I have an iPhone 12 mini and I not perform a “Reset all settings” but only change that option.

@AndreTheGeek could you try to tell to Apple developers to investigate in more specific way and in particular to Camera Format settings?

You can report it here. https://www.apple.com/feedback/

I've been doing some more troubleshooting to try and figure this out. Because it is so consistent (same pictures upload if I disable and re-enable Photo Stream), I started to look at the photos' embedded EXIF information. No clues.

I did get a change though when I did this. I have a MacBook, iPad and iPhone. I turned off Photo Stream, then turned on iCloud Photos on the iPhone and the Macbook. I left the iPad without iCloud Photos, but left Photo Stream on.

I waited until all my photos had synced to iCloud (all photos showed up on MacBook), then I enabled Photo Stream on the phone again. Magically, new photos I took on the phone were now showing up in Photo Stream on the iPad.

I turned everything off again, and got rid of the iCloud photos, then put things back the way they were: Photo Stream on for both the iPad and iPhone. Back to the same issue: only a few iPhone pictures go.

This may not help, but it is a clue. I might switch to iCloud Photos, but I'm not sure I just want everything mixed in together. I like having the "additional" folder called Photo Stream. Hopefully they will fix it. Based on what I've seen with "updates" so far, it doesn't seem that they are even aware of the issue. And I can't find anyone except you who has the exact same issue as me. There's got to be some condition you and I both meet - a setting perhaps. I'm running out of ideas though.

Yes, I do tricks like that too. Or just AirDrop it to myself.

It's definitely a bug specific to this phone (iPhone 12 Pro). My wife's SE 2020 is Photo Streaming just fine, and so are our iPads.

Upon further testing (resetting, turning photo stream off and on, etc.), it’s always the same photos that make it to PhotoStream. There is some decision being made that certain photos will not go. I cannot see any logic. There's nothing specific that’s different about the ones that don’t go. It’s a very annoying bug.

I have the same issue!

I have an iPhone 12 Mini..so maybe the bug is not related to AppleProRAW feature.

When I take a picture over wifi network, it upload on my photo stream immeditly.

When I take a picture over mobile network and then I connect my iPhone on a wifi network, picture does not upload on my photo stream.

BUT, when I take a screenshot over mobile network and then I connect my iPhone on wifi network, screenshot is uploaded on my photo stream immediatly.

It is a really strange behaviour!

I tried to disable, reboot and re-enable my photo stream on both my MacBookPro and my iPhone, but I have not solve the issue.

Both, iPhone and Mac, are runnnig the latest software version: MacOS BigSur 11.1 and iOS 14.4

If someone have idea to how to solve this issue, please let me know!

Looks like it's still not fixed in 14.5.1. Just took 3 photos, and only one went to Photo Stream.

Same here - I've done extensive testing, erasing/disabling Photo Stream and re-enabling it, and the same few photos go, and the same other ones stay behind. It appears to be only the iPhone 12 Pro. My iPad seems to update Photo Stream just fine.

This sounds like a different issue from mine. Mine chooses some and omits others - the choice is consistent. It always chooses the same photos. The ones that go, go quickly every time. It's choosing only a small number of my photos, and purposely omitting most of them. If I reset/delete, then set it up again, exactly the same photos get uploaded, and the same ones get skipped.

Something also tells me it won't. Very strongly tells me. It must not be affecting too many people, so there's some obscure condition that you and I are encountering.

In fact, I'd say it's worse. I only get about 1 in 20 images going to Photostream now from my phone. Images from my iPad go to PhotoStream just fine.

I think we're on our own for this bug.