Reminders - phone app & watch
I recently got my first Apple Watch, a series 5. All available phone apps were copied to the watch. Everything is working as it should. Reminders are showing up & alerting on both phone and watch as expected.
However, I have a reminder - which I deleted from my phone almost two years ago - that keeps showing up on the watch, and only on the watch (the reminder does not alert on my phone) every night at 8:30. The first time, I deleted the repeat setting on the reminder, and marked the reminder as completed. The second time, I searched the reminders app on my phone for this specific reminder. I found it in the completed reminders, where I individually deleted every.single.occurance. related to this reminder, where it had repeated every night when I originally set it up. It now appears NO WHERE on my reminders app when I search for it, but it is STILL alerting me on my watch every night at 8:30. The reminder no longer exists - yet I still get an alert on my watch. What's going on?? How do I fix this?? Please do not tell me to delete the reminders app and re-install. That's not going to happen - I rely on this list way too much to take the chance on losing the reminders saved in the app. There has to be some other place this reminder is hiding, that somehow has only become active when I got the watch a week ago.
Apple Watch Series 5, watchOS 7