I keep receiving Billing Problem emails from you all for subscriptions that have been cancelled and/or are no longer on any of my devices. They are billed through Apple and I cannot figure out how to make the billings stop.

Hi lbarad,

Welcome to the Apple Support Communities!

We understand that you're receiving emails regarding a billing problem from Apple. Since we're all users here, we don't have access to your account to determine why this is happening but it's typically because a previous purchase may not have been cleared. You can learn more here: If your payment method is declined in the App Store or iTunes Store

You may consider contacting Apple directly to help you to determine why you're receiving these emails. They're best suited to look into this further with you. You can find their contact details at the bottom of the article we've included above.

Take care!