CurdNerd wrote:
I am synching the entire library, so this is not the cause. There are no videos or voice memos,
I'm often accused (by my manager) of going into too much detail, but here's a textbook case where not providing enough detail has caused you to overlook something important.
---------------------------
So, let's go through this and hopefully I can point out something to you.
First of all, you didn't mention podcasts, which I had listed as a possible cause. Considering your frustration with the discrepancy, I think it will be worth your while to check, just to make sure.
But here's the really important point: sync entire library and sync only ticked songs and videos are not mutually exclusive; you can have both options set on without causing issues. Now, you may be thinking (but not mentioning here) that that's illogical, but no, it isn't. If you have both options turned on for a specific device, iTunes will sync your entire library - except, if you untick a song in the library. This prevents the song from being added to devices (such as your phone), or removes a song if it was on the device. It keeps the song in your library, but the song will not be played by iTunes in either normal mode or shuffle mode. Such songs can be played if desired, but only by specifically selecting them to play, one at a time.
Again, you may be thinking, what's the point of that? Well, I have two reasons why I use this particular trick:
- Seasonal songs: I have Christmas songs in my Library (some of which are rated as 4 or 5 stars), but obviously, I don't want them to play on my iPod (or in iTunes) outside of the Christmas season. I especially don't want them to play in the height of summer when my iPod is shuffling my favourites Playlist. So on 6th January I untick them all (I have them in a Playlist to make them easier to find) and at the next Sync of my iPod with my library, the unticked Christmas songs are removed. Crucially, they remain in my Library and on 30th November, I tick the songs again and when I next Sync my iPod, the songs go back onto my iPod
- Disliked songs: when I buy a new album I add it to my iPod which means that the first time I hear some of the songs may be on the iPod. If I dislike a particular song I give it a 1 star rating, which sounds counter-intuitive, but I only use the 1 star rating for disliked songs, which leaves a further four star options to use for favourites. Those 1 star songs go into a Smart Playlist so that they're easy to find in my library, and when I'm next performing library maintenance they can be unticked (or even deleted from my library). Hey presto - job done
Back to the actual discrepancy: as mentioned, erratic syncing has been an issue for quite a while now, but I see no prospect of Apple ever fixing the problem. But if this is what's causing your incomplete syncs, you should think yourself lucky. I have slightly fewer songs in my library, but a typical sync leaves me with a far greater number that are supposed to be on my iPod, but don't make it.
As I am writing this I testing a Sync to demonstrate my claims - but would you believe it, not only has every song I selected made it to my iPod - but the totals sill don't' match. I use Sync selected playlists, artists, albums and genres to manage my iPod since I don't have enough room to fit all my music on it. But look at the numbers:
and
How can that be I wonder? But I don't wonder for too long since it would be a waste of my time. I'll probably not resolve the issue. All I know is that I now have all the music on my iPod that I expect to be there. That's what matters to me.