Cloning internal disk with Catalina to partition on external USB

To run important legacy software, I need to have a machine running High Sierra. I recently got a late 2012 Mac mini which has Catalina installed. I'm presently booted from a High Sierra clone on a USB external. Normally, I would make a bootable clone of my internal drive on an external USB partition, in case I needed Catalina for something, and clone High sierra back onto my internal disk. This is my usual approach and I have bootable partitions of several previous OSs. However, Catalina's container disk presents itself as two drives in the Finder and Carbon Copy Cloner can only accept one as source, not the container disk itself. This is new to me. I suppose could just erase and reformat the internal disk and put High Sierra back on it, but it seems like a waste.

Mac mini, macOS 10.13

Posted on Dec 25, 2022 9:45 AM

Reply

Similar questions

11 replies

Dec 30, 2022 10:55 AM in response to Aretin

Make sure to first erase the destination drive as GUID partition and APFS (top option), otherwise you will end up with a mess of mixed file systems.


It is very important that you make the clone while booted into macOS 10.15 Catalina, otherwise it may not work due to the new drive layout used by Catalina. Years ago it was possible to perform the clone while booted into an older OS to clone a newer OS, but the drive layout was still the same (as long as the OS recognized the basic file system such as APFS). The drive layout changes now require the process to be completed while booted to the same or higher version of macOS.


Edit: I should clarify a bit. If you are cloning macOS 10.13, then you can be booted from 10.13+ to make the clone. If you want to clone macOS 10.15, then you will need to be booted from 10.15 when making the clone.

Dec 26, 2022 2:47 AM in response to Aretin

Starting in Catalina - Apple has changed the Drive Structure.


There is a Volume called Macintosh HD which is Read Only and contains the Operating System Files


There is a Volume called Macintosh HD-Data where the User Data is housed.


The Operating System presents to the user the Two Volumes as One


Additional reading for more in-depth explanation of Catalina Drive Structure is below


https://eclecticlight.co/2019/10/08/macos-catalina-boot-volume-layout/

Dec 31, 2022 11:56 AM in response to HWTech

Yes, thank you. I did erase the destination while booted in Catalina. APFS was the only format Disk Util allowed. I erased the internal drive before cloning a bootable High Sierra volume back onto it. Interestingly, though the HS volume was made earlier, from a non-APFS disk, it cloned onto the internal drive without incident and runs smoothly. Using CCC Version 5.1.28 (6213)

Dec 26, 2022 8:36 AM in response to Owl-53

Thank you. I'm familiar with the basic principles. My question was more specific: How can I get Carbon Copy Cloner to clone a volume with this dual drive OS to an external volume? The version of CCC I have will only allow one volume as source and the internal disk on which Catalina resides shows up in the Finder and in CCC as two volumes, a"container disk" which cannot be selected as a source in CCC Version 4.1.24 (4660).

Dec 30, 2022 4:31 AM in response to Owl-53

I finally have things as I would wish. Catalina is parked on an external drive just in case I need to boot in an OS that won't run many of my principal applications. High Sierra is now my internal boot drive. Much of this is due to good advice I got here, and some due to computer voodoo. Example: I never did figure out why the command and option keys on my Bluetooth keyboard had abruptly decided to swap actions, command behaving like option and vice versa, but when, for some reason unknown, settings in the modifier keys part of the keyboard preferences finally decided to stick instead of reverting every time the panel was opened, I was able to deliberately choose opposite actions for the command and option keys and they perversely began to operate in the normal way. Solutions like that are never entirely satisfying because they are not understood. Voodoo!

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Cloning internal disk with Catalina to partition on external USB

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.