mesh network suggestions and thier respective privacy policies

Hi All,


I need to upgrade my old airport network that is dropping connections. I've been holding out for a long time to keep my apple network going. Sadly Apple seems to not want to release a mesh network product. What do you all use?


I'd like to avoid Eero because of Amazon's takeover.

I thought Asus had some good products but I googled around and saw that they also were "caught" with some questionable practices.

Does anyone like Linksys or another mesh product/brand?


I was thinking of spending a bit more for a 6E network. Do I need it? Absolutely not! But I do try to have my networks last "forever" and who knows what our needs are in 5 - 10 years?


I have a 3500 sqft house on one level. We stream one 4k stream and possibly 2 1080p at the same time. Other than that half dozen devices plus homekit devices.


Has anyone used the synology mesh network? I have an old NAS on DSM 6 and really like it. I know they have a NAS background but not how their networking products are.


Thanks for any and all advice,

Philly

Posted on Mar 12, 2023 9:05 AM

Reply

Similar questions

7 replies

Mar 13, 2023 10:06 AM in response to Phillyman

FWIW. Trying to help you towards a solution will be a tad difficult as what would work best for you would require a lot more information ... and, better still, running a wireless site survey. Something that you may want to hire a networking consultant for.


In my case, I replaced my Apple networking ecosystem with that from Ubiquiti. I went with the UniFi line as I wanted to use my home's Ethernet backbone to its full advantage. I have yet to regret that decision, but if you want all wireless connections, that would not be the right solution for you. Ubiquiti also has mesh options.


... and, if mesh is the way you want to go, then I suggest that you look at mesh systems that support a independent wireless backhaul. That means, each wireless access node would use a separate radio for network interconnectivity. Systems that have those are by: Asus (one you seem to have already decided against), Linksys, Netgear, & Ubiquiti's Amplify Alien line.

Mar 15, 2023 8:34 AM in response to Phillyman

Phillyman wrote:

I've ordered the homekit router from Linksys. The model number escapes me but it was an Atlas Pro. How can I tell if it has a wireless backhaul?

One method would be if the wireless router is identified as "Tri-Band." That would mean it would have three separate wireless radios ... one, specifically for communicating between mesh points. That one would be the "backhaul." The Atlas Pro appears only to provide two radios. However, there are other Linksys "mesh" systems that are Tri-Band.


One great source for when you are comparing routers is the SmallNetBuilder site.

Mar 16, 2023 9:58 PM in response to Tesserax

Thank you for your input. I made a mistake I got the wrong model with the Atlas Pro since that didn't have the homekit support (returned it). SO I went with the previous generation wifi six (MX12600). In the specs it has tri band but doesn't use "4800" (frequency). I don't live in a very wifi congested area so I'm not too worried plus this network is ridiculously overpowered for my ISP line. But the airport was struggling with the amount of devices and the lag was an issue with some homekit stuff.


Ill check out their site and see what they say. In my ideal world I would have had a 6E mesh network with homekit support without needing to take out a mortgage. The prices will come down but I was shocked at the cost of the 6E mesh systems.


Again Thanks,

Philly

I'll

Mar 17, 2023 9:05 AM in response to Phillyman

Phillyman wrote:

In the specs it has tri band but doesn't use "4800" (frequency).

FWIW. The numbers after "AC," like AC4800, refers to the sum of all the bandwidth that can theoretically be delivered by each band/frequency that the router provides ... not the radio frequency. So, for example, if you have a router that has a maximum bandwidth of 450 Mbps on the 2.4 GHz band, and 1300 Mbps on the 5 GHz band, it would be "rated" as AC1750.


There is a catch though. A wireless client typically can only connect to one of those bands and in that case the other band's bandwidth goes unused. So, in the above example, it would get either a total bandwidth of either 450 or 1300, depending on which radio it connects to ... NOT 1750 on either.

Mar 17, 2023 9:30 AM in response to Tesserax

Very Interesting. I just assumed it was another company just putting semi random numbers in their product descriptions. My issue is most likely less the actual speed as it is reliability and stability with more and more devices on the network.


I've done some file transfers and have not been impressed. My old airport extreme could get higher rates but your explanation helps. BUT I have noticed the responsiveness and overall coverage (3 nodes versus 1 router and a repeater DUH) being more reliable and better.


I'll test it out some more and if it serves my purpose than I'll most likely keep them.


Tesserax thank you for giving advice and explaining the weird world of wireless networking. What do you currently use or recommend for most tech interested households?


Philly

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

mesh network suggestions and thier respective privacy policies

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.